SelectHomeWarrantyReviews 955

Bought a 5½ -year policy from Select Home Warranty ("SHW") in Nov 2022 for $2500. On 7/21/23 my clothes dryer stopped working; Filed a claim online on 7/23; rec'd email & text messages on 7/24 that a tech would come 7/26 between 8am & noon. On 7/26: No show, no call. Rec'd email/text msgs on 7/27 that the tech would come 7/27 between 8am & noon. Again no show, no call. On 7/28 a tech arrived, diagnosed the problem & said he'd draft a report & send it to SHW, who would order parts & have them sent to me, then I should call the tech to come back to do the repair.

On 8/4 we called SHW to check on the claim; were told the parts had not been ordered yet. We req'd they be ordered immediately & shipped overnight; rep said he'd see what he could do. On 8/15 we called SHW, were told they rec'd the report over 2 weeks ago: the dryer could not be fixed & they were waiting on a determination from their Resolution Dept. I req'd that SHW email me a copy of the report; they told me I needed to get it from the tech. Left several messages for the tech but have not rec'd any reply.

On 8/16 (today) I rec'd an email saying they had approved a $185 reimbursement (my dryer is 5 yrs old & cost nearly $700), but I must repair or replace the unit myself, send SHW the "paid invoice", and then wait to receive a "Reimbursement Form" to sign/return before they'd send a check.

So I've been without a clothes dryer for nearly a month & it's still broken. I emailed SHW to cancel my policy & expect a full refund. There's no reason my dryer can't be repaired, the tech missed app'ts & I have not rec'd the report. The delay is unacceptable & their rep gave us erroneous info re: parts. No one followed up on the claim, their offer is insultingly low & requires unnecessary paperwork.

SHW's website says "We'll repair your covered item. You'll pay a minimal service fee. It's that simple." This is completely false; nothing has been simple about this claim. I'm extremely dissatisfied with SHW. I'm curious to see how they respond to my request for a full refund; if they resolve this matter acceptably, I'll come back & revise my review. Until then, I would strongly advise NOT purchasing a home warranty from this company.

1 STAR BECUASE I CAN'T LEAVE 0.

After making a claim on our washer, they sent a technician over who spent less than 10 minutes to investigate our machine. Never touched it, never ran it, never looked at. Just took down the model number and claimed it was the mother board. After googling the error myself it's a pump or drain error. This company won't send anyone else out to look at the machine and are only giving us a fraction of the cost of a new appliance.

Definitely rethinking our business with them- especially since we call about claims the calls are outsourced and accents are so strong it's impossible to have a conversation or understand what should be done.

VERY TIRED OF ALL THE CRAP IT TAKES TO GET ANY ACTION.

I bought a policy from them on Nov. 11,2023, and on December 21,2023, my dishwasher broke so I placed a claim to them. They refused to pay for repair citing their policy of 30-day coverage before a claim can be made! I'm not sure what calendar or calculator they are using! They ignored my attorney's letters to them so I have filed a claim with the States review board.
I continued to pay my monthly premiums until the end of July when I called and asked them to cancel because I was selling my condo and reminded them their service was lousy. They kept me on the phone for almost 1 hour trying to upsell me while transferring me from one person to another who would try even harder to upsell me to KEEP A POLICY ON A HOUSE I WAS SELLING IN A FEW DAYS! They were all like robots not listening to my reason for cancelling! I ended up having to scream at them to cancel my account for them to eventually agree to do so with a refund, only to have ANOTHER DEBIT TAKEN OUT four days later and no refund! The 'Sponserer's' reviews are paid for so don't be fooled by them.
I am a real estate investor and have relationships with thousands of other investors; I will certainly warn them all against this company!

In my 43 years of living, I have never been this disgusted by a company. For the past four months, I have been in dispute with Select Home Warranty (SHW) about an appliance issue I won't bore readers with. Suffice it to say, I have quoted from the contract to support my argument, but still, nothing. I have sent lengthy emails stating my case and spoken to numerous customer service reps about the issue. Each time I call in (because good luck on getting SHW to contact you re. An issue in writing or via phone), it is obvious my emails haven't been read. The company has no regard for customers' time and no integrity to uphold its contractual obligations. Keep in mind, the salespeople are quick, efficient, and American; however, the customer service reps are all based off-shore and speak poor English. Their area of expertise is giving customers the polite run-around. SHW brags about its customer service being available 24/7, but the fact is the customer service reps have no authority to help the customer in any real way, and apparently, are not permitted to connect customers to anyone with authority. SHW is fond of quoting the lowest service call fee in the industry. That may be, but based on our experience, you will be getting low-bid service techs with dubious qualifications. Claims are extremely slow to process, require extensive documentation, and in the end, they will try to find a reason to deny the claim. If, by chance, you are successful in obtaining a small claim reimbursement, you will wait months for the check. If you read through the positive reviews, it seems they generally refer to the sales process and the contractual coverage. There are very few positive reviews from customers who have actually tried to file a claim – you'll need to look in the one-star ratings for those.

Paid $4,730 dollars for rental home warranty coverage (5 years' worth) contract# *******, tried to file a small claim for a refrigerator that went out Aug 1. Received nothing but the run around from this company. 7 different calls from 7 different Select Home Warranty "agents" from the Philippines; each asking identical questions and promising "We are attempting to contact a repair person" I have requested a charge back from my Credit Card company and I also plan to file a consumer complaint with The NJ Attorney General for fraud. This company needs to be shut down for operating in bad faith. Please do not waste your time with them, they will take your money and not pay claims.

Simply stated, they fail on all accounts. Poorest customer service I have ever seen, they don't do what they say they will do.

You file a claim and within a few hours you will get an email telling you your claim is denied. No one calls to discuss, just denied.

I have filed many claims with this company and only one has been paid. The last claim was the final straw. My A/C broke (when it was 100 degrees outside). They took weel over a week to approve the claim, then wanted to see the last 3 years of maintenance records for the A/C, knowing I bought this warranty with the house purchase. NEVER BUY FROM THIS COMPANY!

I signed up with Select Home Warranty on 8/3/21 and paid Select $1417 for a 3 year contract. I needed a repair service for my rental unit which is not conveniently nearby.
My first claim was for an air conditioner fix in June 2022. My tenant complained because it was taking Select so long (a couple weeks) to send someone out. Since it was taking Select so long to send someone out, I used my own repairman to fix the problem. Select attributed the delay in finding a repairman due to demand caused by hot weather. However, it only took me a few phone calls to find someone who could come out the next day.
I submitted another claim in August 2022 to repair a leaking refrigerator. This same problem reoccurred a month later. When I requested Select to send someone to repair, they said I had used up all of my credits and would not honor my request despite my telling them they didn't fix this problem the first time. I ended up again finding my own repair service who replaced the evaporator fan motor and defrosted and drained the lines as needed. I was charged $563 which Select refused to pay. I contacted Select several times but Select was unresponsive.
By this time, I was so unhappy with Select I asked them to cancel my contract and refund the unused prorated portion of my contract. I figured I was due approximately 2/3rds of my initial payment or approximately $935. Later I was shocked to only receive $61.69. When I called, they told me according to the contract, they subtracted the previous service calls plus some cancellation fee. What a rip-off! I'm partially to blame for not seeing this in their contract and not thoroughly researching the best home warranty companies.
I'm writing this to alert any potential Select Warranty customers to make sure to read the contract's fine print.
Also despite several requests for a full accounting of how they arrived a the $61 payment, I haven't received a detailed accounting.

Paid this company for 21 months never filed a single claim. My AC unit was not hitting the set point on the thermostat. I filed a claim, and the repairman that select sent out didn't even put a cage on the HVAC system. He said it might have a Freon leak and might be low a pound or two. So he called select home warranty or authorization and they said no we're not covering anything. And by the way we're going to charge you $100 for doing absolutely nothing. I Paid my $75 cancellation fee and cancelled my contract. Telling all my friends and neighbors just what kind of company they are, highly recommend you keep looking for a good home warranty company I know there are much better out there than this company.

I called to have our ice maker repaired, just purchased their Platinum Plan in May. Said it was not covered but for another $500, service fee and not including parts they would add it to the plan. No, please cancel the contract and refund our money. Sorry no supervisor available, will contact you in 48hrs (India call center). NO, after some discussion and letting them know, they were dealing with a Disabled Combat Vet and a retired govt employee, ok will contact you in 4hrs. Guess what no call, just an email informing us to call them. Called them (again in India call center), no supervisor available will contact you in 48hr. Contacted their claim complaints, general information, customer service and marketing partners departments all by email. NO CONTACT BACK. This was yesterday. Avoid this company!

AC went out, tech shows up with no tools, takes 3 weeks to get parts and return. Installs parts then unit still does not work. Takes 2 more weeks to determine the AC is not going to be covered, 2 70 year old tenants sweating for weeks, I had to put them up in a hotel for their safety.

On July 7,2022, I signed a 3-year contract with Select Home Warranty LLC to cover my appliances. On Fri, Jun 2,2023, I submitted a claim to fix my washer. On Monday, June 19th the technician arrived at my home to replace the parts which were sent to me by the warranty company. The technician was not able to repair the washer as the part was defective and another required part was not sent to me at all. I contacted the warranty company multiple times asking them to send me new working parts and fix the unit but do not get any feedback from them. The only solution they offered is $200 which is not enough to replace the unit. Considering this, I asked the warranty company to terminate my policy as I do not get any help from them and reimburse my prorated payment which I made when bought this policy. However, the representatives of this company keep saying that they will charge me for the parts even though the part was defective and another required part was not sent to me. I agree to send the defective part back to them but they refuse to accept it and want to charge me for it. It sounds like fraud from them because they are sending the defective part to the customers and refusing to get them back.

I filed a claim on my AC unit. They wanted 3 years of maintenance records. They denied my claim on those grounds. I don't know anyone who keeps their maintenance records. No other warranty I've used has ever asked for such. It's just an excuse not to pay. Scammers

Their goal is to pay out as little as possible, don't trust this scam of a company. They market that they have the highest payouts on single claims, they market that age of appliance doesn't matter, they will sell you the first 2-3 lines of the contract which offers to repair/replace, but then they bury deep in the contract that they barely cover anything and they can, at their leisure, write down the value of your appliance to next to nothing and offer you a tiny payout AFTER you've paid the $65 service fee. Additionally, all calls get routed offshore. There's no way to speak to someone in the U.S. and theres no way to have anyone take responsibility. I would recommend you take your business elsewhere, otherwise, they'll earn your premiums up until your first claim, after which, you'll cancel because of how terrible their service is. We've waited over 6 weeks to have a fridge repaired, and they finally offered us $200... our tankless water heater stopped working, rather than repair, they offered us $225. Note, this is after us paying the $65 fee both times. Their goal isn't to provide warranty service, their goal is to steal your premiums.

My Dish Washer Quit Working April 3 Select Home Warranty Has Been Giving Me The Run Around Every One I Talk To Tells Me Something Different They Say They Will Give Me $150.00 For My Dish Washer Today Is May 24 I Will Not Hold My Breath Very Bad Company I Will Every Body Not To Get This Warranty They Do Not Tell You The Truth They Just Want Your $800'00

This company should be investigated. Due to their constant lies to cover repairs in a home, which they ultimately refused to, a disabled elderly woman has been left in a home with vapors and spillage. She has become physically ill. Letters have been sent to the CEO, requesting intervention, but no one is helping. We will be contacting the media.

Worst company ever. They have NO customer service. Took the 3 1/2 weeks to return a phone call that they said would happen within 24 hours. My 4000.00 claim has been open for 16 months. They only want to honor it for 400.00. They never even sent anyone out. I had to do all the work and I did it the best I could. Now demanding they send there own tech out. Worst company ever!