Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook
On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.
Personalization Mall has a rating of 1.9 stars from 527 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Personalization Mall most frequently mention customer service, tracking number and christmas gifts. Personalization Mall ranks 151st among Promotional Products sites.
We monitor reviews for authenticity
We ordered 2 outdoor door mats on 07/07/18 with the longitude and latitude for our town 32 deg 24 N 80 deg 86 W. We never received an email confirmation. Mats arrived on 07/14 with
33.23
-80.*******. The mats are thin rubber with a felt top. They are indoor mats.
We emailed and called and were told that the coordinates were what we had sent them. The order was matched on 07/09 by a O. Oyetunde, was the order filled oversees, was there a translation problem?
The customer service rep said it was our mistake and we would have to reorder and repay, no returns accepted. I asked to speak to the manager, initially she refused but put me through to a voicemail, sounded like an overseas call center, no return call yet. We have disputed the charge, hopefully Personalization Mall. Com management will do the right thing and refund Chase the $42.00
I just received my shipment of 6 beer mugs for our 50th wedding anniversary The box was packed very well and there was absolutely no damage to the mugs They were very nicely engraved and were extremely well constructed They were better than I imagined
This company has terrible customer service they dont trust there customers...
Order a keychain and it never arrived when i contacted them they say check by neighbors then the open investigation for 20 bucks
I order a gift for Fathers Day and take the priority mail so guaranteed that will receive it before Fathers Day and didnt received it Im so disappointed I will never order again in here...
I received an blanket with personal embroidery as a gift which was nice. I ordered one for someone and it was a mess you couldnt make out what it said at sll. I called customer service and sent pictures of both and did not offer any help.
To my surprise they called me and said that they would refund one of the charges! They also said they were both charged on PayPal which I know I entered my charge card info so not sure what really happened. Just Happy to receive a call and a REFUND. Thank you!
They do not want to refund... I ordered 2 items and the first time the processing did not complete and I tried to use PayPal so I waited over an hour as it stated not to leave this page So because it didn't complete --- I did not go through with accepted PayPal but They processed the order and I had no way of knowing so I ordered again and paid with CC. I left for my vacation and when I came back there were 2 boxes waiting for me at home! I called and they said there was nothing they could do about it. Finally I will get a store credit if I pay to ship it back. I will not be ordering from them again. I would advise others to go somewhere else
On 5/21/18, I spoke with "Patty" who was rude, kept interrupting me when I tried to speak, insulted me by talking tome like I was a child who could not add and figure out dates on a calendar. I - very clearly - informed her that I was incredibly displeased with them, and her response was "There is nothing I can do". Well now, there is quite a lot I c an do - like NEVER shop with them again, and leave negative reviews warning everyone else of the same!
We apologize that our customer service team wasn't able to provide the outstanding customer service experience we always strive for. We have contacted our Customer Service Manager and she will be reaching out to you shortly to try and make this right.
DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE. Came across this website to buy a gift for Mothers Day, because I noticed that they offered "GUARANTEED BY MOTHERS DAY SHIPPING", so I went ahead and purchased this shipping. My order was supposed to be in the Friday before Mothers Day. Friday rolled around, and I had no package. I contacted the company, who made ME (THE CUSTOMER) call FedEx to track it down. I called FedEx and they said sorry we received an empty package, you'll have to contact the shipper! UNBELIEVABLE. Therefore, I contacted the company back and all they said is they'd refund it unless I wanted them to make another one, but it wouldn't be here until next week ( the week after MOTHERS DAY). WHY offer this "guaranteed service" if you're not going to live up to it. There are many, many other personalization websites to order gifts from so I HIGHLY recommend to avoid this place at all costs. I had to scramble last minute to find another Mothers Day gift and it was nothing but stressful. Unprofessional employee that I had to deal with as well. I asked to be contacted by the manager Monday, and the days almost over and I still haven't got a call back.
We apologize for the issue with your order and that you weren't able to have your Mother's Day gift in time. Please reply to our private message with your order number so we can have our Customer Service Manager contact you to try and make this right.
This company is absolutely terrible! They do NOT ship all of your items and when they don't, they refuse to take full responsibility for it. They mess up customized items and then give you the run around so they don't have to replace the item or refund your money. Their customer service is horrendous! I was hung up on and no one ever responds to emails sent to their support line. Stay away from this company. Spend your money with a company who appreciates their customers.
We apologize that UPS lost your package, Andrea. Our customer service team requested the investigation and once UPS responded saying the package was lost, our customer service team offered to replace or refund you for your order. We apologize for the inconvenience this has caused. If you would like to discuss the issue further, please send us a private message and we can have our customer service manager reach out to you to further explain the process. Thank you.
Their workmanship, their guarantee, and "their word" are all worthless. If you still choose to order something "personalized," you'd better send the recipient a magnifying glass to go along with it.
R. Stack
We're sorry to hear you weren't happy with your personalized gift Rose. Our customer service manager will be reaching out to you shortly to try and rectify the situation.
You aren't actually allowed to create "personalized" gifts as they choose weather your personal life is appropriate for the gift. Apparently, only "G" rated items are acceptable... sorry adults with a sense of humor. Shop elsewhere.
I ordered an engraved key chain for my husband whose father recently died. You can't even see the engraving it looks like a blank key chain. I sent an email to the company and they basically said" too bad... even if we re do it it will look the same". I've paid over $20 for a keychain you can't even read what it says. VERY poor quality and disappointing customer service.
We're sorry to hear about the issue with your order Sara. Please reply to our private message with your order number. Once we have your order number we'll be able to look up your order and try to make this right. Thank you!
I ordered 2 Family Bibles for wedding gifts. I also purchased, for $6.99 each, gift boxes for both of them. One of the gift boxes was nice the other one was ripped in four places. The large box they arrived in was not damaged at all. I called and requested another gift box and was told by customer service that they couldn't send me just a gift box. I was very disappointed that they would even send a box so chewed up and ratty looking. They said they would reimburse me the $6.99 which is ok but I wanted the gift box I purchased.
Renee,
We apologize that you received a defective box and that our customer service team failed to provide you with the best service. Please reply to our private message with your order number so we can look into this issue and try to make this right.
I will have to admit that after reading all those terrible reviews i went ahead and bought a stuffed bunny with my daughters name on it, and against all odds I got a great product, so soft, good size, the letters are super cute, i got it on time. Absolutely loved it!
Thank you so much for the kind words Melissa! We're so happy to hear your daughter loved her personalized bunny and that you were happy with your order!
Despite having a quality issue in the past that the company refused to fix and having read numerous negative reviews, against my better judgement I ordered a personalized, holiday teacher gift that was paid for and given by my daughter's entire kindergarten class. The wording on the shadow box was correct, but the screen that is the background was the incorrect color. I ordered a tan screen, but the company personalized my order on a gray screen. When I called to inform them, at first the rep. Said that my item would be replaced and done so in time to present the teacher with her correct gift. However, as I've experienced before, the "quality control" department sent me through a series of "steps" that are set in place to deter the customer from taking action and they actually denied sending me a corrected item, claiming that I in fact had received a tan screen as I had ordered. They only offered to credit me back 20% of my order, which amounted to a whole $5.00, while I paid almost $10.00 in shipping alone! Only someone with very poor vision could possibly say that I received anything but a dark gray screen. If I had in fact received a tan screen as they claim, then this company grossly misrepresents their products and color choices. They proceeded to lie about what customer service had informed me of, told me that my item only had one screen color choice while the item actually has 5 screen color choices, and were extremely rude and unprofessional. I've never in my life experienced such complete deceitfulness from a company and total lack of competency. They should be ashamed of themselves for robbing a customer and I strongly advise everyone to stay away from this horrible business.
We apologize for the issue with your order Elizabeth. We would like to try and make this right for you - please reply to our private message with your order number or the email address you used to make your purchase so we can look into this for you. Thank you!
This is a very unfair one way change of policy with no advance notice showing no respect nor care for loyal customers. The reward points were worth more in the old system. This is a rip off for people who shop PMall and save their reward points to get the best value. The way how this new change is pushed out is ridiculous. PMall sent an email to MPR members notifying the update and changed (lowered) the point exchange rate at the same time. PMall is taking advantage of their customers and practically stealing from them. I am very disappointed that PMall does business like that.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts Fam. Please reply to our private message with your email address so we can make this right. Thank you!
Stay clear of these guys. I ordered a customized blanket from their website. When I entered my shipping address it estimated delivery in 8-10 business days for $17.99. I thought this was a bit pricy but paid anyway because I live in Hawaii. Over 3 weeks later my order has still not arrived! The special occasion was missed. Personalization Mall has refused to issue a refund on any portion.
We apologize your personalized gift didn't arrive in time Jake. Please reply to our private message with your order number so we can try to make this right. Thank you!
Spent hourscrafting some funny messages for some small gifts for my husband, placed the order then received an email saying "We are unable to process your order due to the nature of the image or language supplied to us. Your order is currently on hold." Chatted with the customer service, it turned out to be certain words I used in the messages, TO MY HUSBAND, are considered "inappropriate"... What I wrote was "I love $#*!ing you... oops, I meant I $#*!ing love you". Can someone tell me if this is funny because clearly, as the customer service said "not everyone has a sense of humor". Do not order from here if you do have a sense of humor, you have been warned! P.S., as I mentioned the time and energy wasted for the order, the customer service representative clearly did not care. Please guys, DO NOT order from here, it's not worth it!
We apologize for the inconvenience Panda. Our system automatically flags questionable language, however we would still like to help you complete this order as you'd like. Please reply to our private message with your order number so we can try and make this right. Thank you!
We ordered a canvas print of my family. My husband and son were in front of my daughter and I. My daughter and my foreheads were on the side of the picture! Looks like we were cut off at the eyes. Meanwhile my son and husband have their full body in the picture. Seriously? Why didn't they center it? When I complained they said they would give me a "discount" when I reordered it! Shana R. Was my customer service rep. Just ridiculous! Stay away - there are many other choices out there.
We apologize for the issue with your order Jill. Please reply to our private message with your order number. Once we have your order number we can have our customer service manager look into this issue and contact you to rectify the situation.
E-comm flow is a huge problem. Took way too long to construct mug. The site flow does not make it clear how to save and move onto the next picture. Too many instances where info is not saved and you have to constantly re-do your work!
Dear Eitan, We apologize for the technical difficulties you experienced while trying to place your order. Our customer service team would be glad to help walk you through the ordering process to make sure you don't encounter any more issues. Could you please reply to our private message with your email address so we can have our customer service manager contact you directly? Thanks!
Answer: Their website looks nice but their quality is trash! Don't trust your precious memories to them. Just awful
Answer: They won't fix it. I called customer service and they pretty much said to bad. Also they may make you a new one but charge you 50% and the shipping charge.
Answer: I wouldn't if I was you. Use another company if you can. I haven't received the order I placed over 20 days ago. Don't recommend them at all. My experience.
Gift giving made easy! Shop thousands of unique, personalized gifts for men, women & kids - for every occasion. Always free personalization & fast shipping.


We apologize for the issue with your order Donna. Can you please reply to our private message with your order number or the email address you used to place the order? As soon as we have that information we can have our Customer Service Manager contact you. Thank you!