GoldbellyReviews 25,789

It's amazing to be able to enjoy food from home without being home!

It was easy to select date and the shipping was free on my order. Food arrived well packaged. This was a gift and the recipient said the cheesesteaks were amazing and were easy to prepare.

New York pizza, what's not to like? My Long Island born recipient was beyond thrilled and can't stop smiling about it! Best gift ever!

How often there was updated communication about my order. I liked all the tracking updates

Being that they have been in business for so long, I felt confident in the quality of their product. But I didn't know how well it would stand up to my dad's memory of having knishes in New York when he was young. Well, they were an amazing and perfect surprise for my parents' 50th anniversary party.

It was well received by the recipients. They loved it.

Everything lol.

The pizzas were delicious, shipping was fast, packing was excellent, ordering was easy.

Best order of pickles we have ever received from Guss's crisp and crunchy green.
Wondering if shipping to Texas in spring and summer spoils them. This last order was fantastic
Thanks

The pies are truly delicious and they came shipped in a little cooler which was really nice.

Not much. The French fry cookies were just OK but the little dip cups were like a petri dish. How can people dip a cookie in this little cup and reuse it. It's so small you could barely fit the cookie in it. Very over priced and very disappointing.

Ice cream delivered to perfection. Flavors outstanding. Nothing but the best from Nancy.
Have been following her work a long time.

Quick delivery & ver nice individual packaging. Best of all, super fresh & super yummy!

I sent this raspberry pie as a gift to my brother. He has been raving about how plentiful the raspberries were in the pie and how delicious it is. It arrived all packaged up to stay cool. Will definitely order from Goldbelly and this bakery again.

Cookies tasted like they sat on a shelf for a week or two and weren't fresh... they were very hard.
Pizza was good other than 3 of the 8 slices were cracked into several pieces.

It was delivered on the day I expected and the product was frozen... also as expected.

The recipient was excited to receive the bagels. Everything was fresh and on time

Its is so easy to order; delivery is precise too :)

Delivery was accurate and on to time, crawfish we're a good size. Taste was good

Great cake it arrived well packaged and rum butter sauce was similarly well packed.

I've been wishing for a local high-quality bagel seller for almost two decades. I finally broke down and found goldbelly, took a chance, and ordered bagels from Kossar's Bagels & Bialys. Wow! Sooooo much better than any other bagels, ever, anywhere (though I've never sampled other New York sellers)! What a treat. They cost more, but are worth every penny!