Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook
On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.
Supermarket Italy has a rating of 3.9 stars from 4,762 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Supermarket Italy most frequently mention fast delivery, customer service and great products. Supermarket Italy ranks 2nd among Grocery sites.
We monitor reviews for authenticity
Not only was one bag of pasta broken open, the second bag expired in August 2022…thus is December 2022
I appreciate the way the fragile items are packaged with care and pretty much have always got what I ordered. Thanks..
I am a returning customer and never had problem with delivery. Unfortunately, the price of this item doubled so I don't order it often any more, just once in a while. They used to offer 3-pack for little better price.
I'm using an Android system to make my selections and the experience is annoying because every time, when I look at any product and push back the site send me to the top of the products list. You can pay attention on this because you are loosing money and many clicks. Other everything is excellent.
Mostly fine. But there was a bit of a bait and switch with the so-called piquillo peppers.
Fresh. Baked well, easy to peel. Could be a tad sweeter.
Purchased as a gift that has yet to be tried.all assumptions point to thorough enjoyment.
This was a great shopping experience. My husband's family is Italian and I was on the search for Italian Long Hots as he lives these on sandwiches and the deli in our town stopped carrying them. This website was a welcomed find and I am positive to return to it for future purchases.
While the products i ordered arrived in order, the shipping materials they arrived in seemed insufficient, and i certainly wouldn't order from here in summer (i live in S. California desert cities). Two fedex thermal packs (one inside another) and two tiny gel packs that were completely thawed to protect 4 lbs of cured meats.
We are testing for the 1st time this on line shopping of some italian products just for Christmas Holidays. We found a good selection of products, good information and shipping services.
I received my order in less than 24 hours. Amazing! I love shopping at Supermarket Italy! Thanks!
I received this within 5 days of ordering, not too long a wait. Got here just in time when I ran out of my last one.
Quality products and quick delivery times. This coming from someone who lives a couple states away from their general location. Frequent discounts and quality packaging.
So much to choose from! The only problem is once I find something I like...it isn't on your catalog the next time I come on! Hopefully it is just out of stock. My daughter-in-law introduced me to DeCecco pastas...she and my son think they taste better than anything available in the grocery stores in our state.
The flavors are so much better
I have been trying for years to find the Sicilia Lemon Juice that I once stumbled on locally. I asked Frankie's Deli (Italian 3rd or 4th generation in Oak Brook IL) If they could carry it but I never found out if they investigated it---but then I think I didn't have the actual name. I knew this was the right one when I saw the bottle--I ordered 10.
The other items were mostly experimental because I've had DeCecco gnocchi and it was superior. Cannot wait until my daughter-in-law cooks for me!
I have 0 complaints with this entire transaction. My package arrived quickly, I was notified every step of the way, it was packaged well, and the olives I got were surprisingly perfect. I won't be buying my olives or maybe anything they offer from anyplace else.
Products purchased to date are fresh and delicious. Great website.

