Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of SelectHomeWarranty

SelectHomeWarranty

2.1

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate SelectHomeWarranty?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

SelectHomeWarranty Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Select Home Warranty is predominantly negative, with numerous customers expressing dissatisfaction regarding service delays, claim denials, and poor customer support. Many reviews highlight a troubling pattern of unfulfilled promises, lack of transparency in policy coverage, and difficulty in obtaining reimbursements. Conversely, a few customers noted the affordability of the plans and positive initial interactions with sales representatives. However, these positive experiences are overshadowed by widespread complaints about the company's reliability and perceived deceptive practices, leading to a strong sentiment among consumers to avoid this service.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
200
value
200
shipping
37
returns
47
quality
185
This company does not typically respond to reviews

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jennifer B.
Unfollow Jennifer B.
Share Review
Report Review

This warranty company has been the worst to deal with. I had a pool pump issue. They made me pay the pool repair man in full and I'm still waiting for my reimbursement. Then my ac went out on a weekend. They couldn't send someone to help me. It was 105° outside so after calling 5 times that day trying to get my repair approved they told me that department doesn't work on the weekends so if I wanted to pay the man myself I could but they couldn't guarantee they would cover the full cost amount. Turns out they won't pay anything because I didn't wait the 3 days to finally hear back from the approval department. So I would have been without ac for 3 days. It was 90° in my house and all they can say is sorry that's our policy. They don't care about customer care whatsoever. So if anything goes wrong with your house on the weekend just forgot having the warranty company pay for it. I called to cancel but they said if I cancel before I get my reimbursement check from my pool repair they will not give me that money back or send me a check, so they will just keep my money. What a joke of a company.

Date of experience: July 17, 2020
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Lorie C.
Unfollow Lorie C.
Share Review
Report Review

This company deserves a -5. They take your money and won't repair a thing. They always have an excuse not to cover repairs clearly covered under your plan. Find a more legitimate company because this company will just take your money.

Date of experience: July 17, 2020
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Perfecto R.
Unfollow Perfecto R.
Share Review
Report Review

WATCH OUT
July 16, 2020

Excuses Excuses and no service available or delays delays plus a 75.00 fee to close your account and prorate your contract. It appears they don't enough people to cover the promises they committed too.

Date of experience: July 16, 2020
California
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Teresa J.
Unfollow Teresa J.
Share Review
Report Review

I spent over 800 dollars for a two year warranty.

In the last year I asked for my plumbing, refrigerator to be fixed and for my air con to be checked.

Only did i get the plumbing checked. And, I had to pay up front for both service call and repair. Plus wait online for 2.5 hours of time to get the approval. So the repair company had to return. Otherwise I would have been charged an hourly for having the repair man wait. He left after 45 minutes of being on hold.

I can go on and on. Suffice it to say, I still not have the air con or refrigerator issue taken care of after two weeks of dealing with this company. They even referred a supplier and had me call to schedule an appointment with a COMPANY THAT DOES NOT DO BUSINESS WITH SELECT HOME-----!

Date of experience: July 13, 2020
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Bob B.
Unfollow Bob B.
Share Review
Report Review

They are a rip-off
July 10, 2020

Had my policy since 2018. My water heater tank was leaking. Called select they denied my claim they said they only covered the components since when is the tank not a component of a water heater.

Date of experience: July 10, 2020
California
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Phillip B.
Unfollow Phillip B.
Share Review
Report Review

Had The Platinum Service Plan for four months, called in a claim for a dripping shower and was told I was not covered. They said they would cover it for another 49.95 a year so I told them to add the 49.95 Fixture coverage and send out a plumber and then they told me, we will be happy to take your money but we will not fix the drip in your shower because it's a preexisting problem. When I ordered the service I was told that I had the top coverage. This is a scam as far as I'm concerned, I canceled the service and called a Plummer. Don't waste your money!

Date of experience: July 9, 2020
Massachusetts
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow anthony l.
Unfollow anthony l.
Share Review
Report Review

Paid 1394 for 3yr contract which they breached and did not fufill thier end of the contract. I paid 45.00 for a repair tech to come out who diagnosed issue with dryer. Weeks went by and then select home warranty stalled and did not authorize repair even though tech told them the cause. I spent months chasing them. Then my refrigerator died. Sane thing all over again. I then requested cancelation of service due to breach. They sent me a chk for 24. 00. 1 and a half year left on contract at 1400 is not 24.00. They will deny service, delay and lie. Do not use this company

Date of experience: July 8, 2020
New York
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow P C.
Unfollow P C.
Share Review
Report Review

Select Home Warranty has terrible customer service. My AC stop working and I called them for service. It took 48 hrs before they assigned a company called Action Services. (Never heard of them). I called the number and this guy with a work truck came the next day. I have a Trane AC unit. He had no idea how to work on it. He said all AC units are the same. He said he will come back the next morning@ 10a after he reads up on unit. He said he will change out the thermostat. Guess work. He was no show the next day. Called Select and they said they would reassign to some1 else and would take another 48 hours before I would get another technician to call. I told them I would call my own technician. They said I could do that but my tech would have to call them before he works on system. I called Michael & Sons. They ck inside unit and saw alarm lights. He said sys had been knocked off line perhaps by power failure. He called Trane sys to assist in resetting system. I called select to approve before and was on hold for 45 min. No 1 ever picked up. I filed claim and receved an email from select it was approved. Its been 2 weeks ago never heard again from select. Called Select and they said their claims dept had to send a RA form for me to fill out. Nothing. I don't expect to receive it. I told Select about their sent tech from Action Services and they said they will put a note on claim. Select is terrible. They have no intention of paying any claim. Their own tech was getting ready to take them to the cleaners for either bogus work or they were going to deny claim. This is not a warranty to have.

Date of experience: July 7, 2020
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Tee R.
Unfollow Tee R.
Share Review
Report Review

This is the most affordable home warranty service out there! They really look out for you and care about you and your home from day one to years in the future! My whole family shops with this company and has not been let down since!

Date of experience: July 6, 2020
Iowa
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Judy C.
Unfollow Judy C.
Share Review
Report Review

Update
July 4, 2020
Updated review

I had a good feeling about Select for a long time. Then On the 29th the day after I wrote a review, I needed my Select Home warranty and They could only find one (1) air conditioner company to come and Service. I called them and was told No Can Do. It will cost more for me to come out and I am not sure when I could get out there. We had already been without Air conditioning for 2 days. Well, I had spent all morning on the phone, I was HOT. I canceled it all.

Date of experience: July 2, 2020

Select Home Warranty
June 30, 2020
Previous review

We have had several home warranty companies. Select seems to be one of the best. I have never had any problems with or do I expect to have any problems. This is our 3 year. I hope it continues.

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
Indiana
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Michael K.
Unfollow Michael K.
Share Review
Report Review

Complaints
July 2, 2020

We chose to work with Select Home Warranty based on their positive reviews we read. We purchased a full home warranty plan one year ago to cover our entire home. A few months after purchasing the plan our heater broke so we contacted SHW for coverage. They sent a mechanic to look at the unit who had no understanding of the issue. We decided to call another professional heating service provider who fixed the issue quickly and charged less than SHW. We tried to get a reimbursement from SHW which took two months of back and forth and only happened when I threatened to cancel my service with them. After 3 months, we had another issue, this time with the A/C. We called our technician again who came to fix the issue. We sent the statement to SHW for reimbursement only to be told that this wasn't covered under the warranty, despite it clearly being covered. Then, last week we had another issue with a leak in our water heater. Again, we called a professional plumber who came to fix it the same day. When we sent the bill back to SHW for reimbursement, they again told us this wasn't covered because leaks with water heaters didn't qualify. After three consecutive cases, it's clear that SHW is running a scam and not reimbursing for services that are clearly covered under their policy. The representative will speak very nicely with you but make sure there are no results at the end. Stay away from this company if you want quality home warranty coverage.

Date of experience: July 2, 2020
Washington
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Christian I.
Unfollow Christian I.
Share Review
Report Review

RUN!
July 1, 2020

I honestly don't have any more time to give to this company, so I will keep it short here and move on.

DO NOT PROTECT YOUR HOME WITH SELECT HOME WARRANTY!

I had two homes with them protected for 3 years and had to cancel both after a year when I realized nothing is going to change with them. They will give you more headaches than peace of mind when it's time to filing a claim or reimbursement.

Worst off, it that when I called to cancel, they kept hanging up the call on me, I had to call multiple times, they refused to disclose my refund balance and said a billing agent will follow up with me later. Long story short, they tried to steal my balance to force me not to cancel, but it was not worth it anymore so I still canceled.

Date of experience: July 1, 2020
Georgia
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Alan C.
Unfollow Alan C.
Share Review
Report Review

Always thought that home warranties were a fight waiting to happen. I had one on a previous home with the big guy and everything from extra costs to changes are an issue. With my new home I went with Select Home Warranty because they were cheaper. I had a problem with my air conditioner and notified Select. I was quickly scheduled with a local 5 star rated company. Yhe next morning by 9 am the problem was repaired. My house is cool again and the service fee was $45, the other company was $125! I was notified by text and email every inch of the process. The whole thing could not have been handled any better. Save money and get better service is a win win situation.

Date of experience: June 30, 2020
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow michelle d.
Unfollow michelle d.
Share Review
Report Review

Had an issue with my dishwasher. Called to file claim, they contacted me immediately to set up time for tech to come out. Seamless process

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
Delaware
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow ann k.
Unfollow ann k.
Share Review
Report Review

Electrical
June 30, 2020

The person I spoke to was helpful and pleasant and explained all to me. The only issue was I had to repeat and repeat and repeat the explanation and she added things not true as "garage opener did not work" when I stated receptacle did not work. She submitted my claim and was pleasant... just explanation barrier.

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Theresa C.
Unfollow Theresa C.
Share Review
Report Review

Sales Agent Superb
June 30, 2020

Fred Lewis sold me a policy in February he was absolutely fantastic went over all the details of the policy with me. Fred made sure that I understood everything I was getting. I called him today because I had a question and he took care of it before we were off the phone. Thank you Fred for always being fantastic.
Terri Costello

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
Ohio
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Mary J.
Unfollow Mary J.
Share Review
Report Review

Easy Peasy
June 30, 2020

Signing up was a breeze. Hope to never need it, but a peace of mind is worth it. Option to have multiple home discount or switch policy to new residence is a relief.

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Kathy B.
Unfollow Kathy B.
Share Review
Report Review

Good service
June 30, 2020

In the months I have been with Select, zi have had efficient and timely service. The call are answered without long delays and the information is gathered in a professional manner.

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Robbie H.
Unfollow Robbie H.
Share Review
Report Review

Customer service representative was very pleasant and concerned about my problem. She explained everything to me which was going to happen recording my claim.

Date of experience: June 29, 2020
New Mexico
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Annette S.
Unfollow Annette S.
Share Review
Report Review

I've yet to take advantage of the Select Home Warranty service, but the initial low-pressure, highly-informative customer service/sales interaction was very pleasant. Hopefully, I'll be as happy with the actual repair services and response time they provide when something goes wrong at my house in the future!

Date of experience: June 28, 2020

From the business

FREE quote! Shield your wallet from home repair expenses with a Select Home Warranty protection plan. Home Warranty Awards "2017 Best In Service" winner.


selecthomewarranty.com
Mahwah, New Jersey, United States
+61
See all photos