Plenty of FishReviews 2,006

Horrible! The profiles seem fake for most girls, they never send anything to you or respond. All talking about finding a good guy or whatever but if you don't look like an athlete or model it's not worth it. It is so bad I can't even delete my profile, such a waste of time. Literally talked to 1 girl for like 4 messages and that was it. And it is not that free, lots of key features can't be used without paying. I would pay a city bus driver to run me over multiple times before I would join and pay for this site. Absolutely worthless!

POF has the fakest people on it's site ever! I was on there eight days and never met a single person, not sure I'd want to with the sleazebags on there, there were exactly three people on there I was maybe interested in meeting, the rest were horrible, but none had any intention of meeting, just phishing and trolling, (not why I joined), the men on there were not anyone you'd want to meet; sooo gross! The people on there also like to get your phone number: IMMEDIATELY, also for phishing.

Like i said its DESRIMINATORY towards MEN! I can PROVE it, first takes 2 people man and woman, each set up account, let the woman go off on the man and the man DO NOT RESPOND just report the message WATCH WHAT HAPPENS UR AZZ WILL GET BOOTED SO FAST! Woman can also say what they want in headline and profile from profanity to sexual comments( which it states CLEARY youll be permenantly kicked off) if you report thier profile AGIN they will BOOT YOU MEN trust me i know my profiles have simply stated i dont date toothless users cheaters and liars well sum1 gets butt hurt and there IS NO VIOLATION in that kinda profile but as soon as a woman doesnt like your answer or you ignore her or report her YOUR DONE THIS IS A P. O. S SITE lol MEN STAY AWAY!

I think maybe 30% of the female profiles are real. The rest are just scammers and fake profiles that pof.com puts up to make it look more like a 50-50 male to female ratio.

Their basic membership is (or at least was) completely free - which makes it OK. However, after contacting about 250 women and not receiving one response, I became a little disappointed. I guess that's where the paid upgrade comes in for some reason.

I have better luck meeting women in bars and the grocery store. Pof.com was a waste of time for me. But if you're young and good looking, you may have a chance at success.

Your review will help others learn about this website.
If you never (and I mean never) have had any luck with a dating service you will do well to avoid Plenty of Fish.com. Unless you are a smokin hot super intelligent well financed bachelor or bachelorette (and why would you use a free dating service if you are?) then you better be prepaired to wait a long (and I mean A LONG TIME LIKE THE REST OF YOUR LIFE!) long time! I have met a few women but most are so scared $#*!less of dating they would do well to not date at all. Of course there are the homely unatractive stay at home home bodies who dare not venture out into the real world of dating but if you want to actually meet someone to have a gratifying real relationship with I would suggest a pay site like Eharmony or Match.com. You will get exactly what you pay for and even less with Plenty of Fish.com. STAY AWAY!
Please do not review if you are affiliated or have a conflict of interest with this website.

I would not recommend this site to Satan himself. It's just a complete waste of precious time. I'm still a member of POF for free but I'm going to delete my account. I haven't gotten very far at all with anyone on POF. It's like every single woman on there likes playing hard-to-get or they're complete and total snobs. I've had women message me to say hi and then when I message them back I don't get a reply back. I've went on three dates-one with one lady who wanted to get too serious too quickly and two dates with another lady who was a very sweet lady but she had been married before and had two kids and she didn't want anymore kids, which is what I want some time after I get married so it didn't work out. Seriously, don't waste your time people.

On my first I saw a really attractive lady but her profile did not seem right (a widow for 3 years & divorced at the same time.). Anyway I thought I would reply but in my Sunday newspaper I was floored to see her in the same photo, same dress etc but this time she was wearing an alert button on a chain around her neck in an advervisement. WOW. Also on Match.com rarely do I find someone in my vicinity but on pop they were all in my area. Looked fishy to me.

Wow I am very surprised to see some people saying that plenty of fish is a fake site? This is hands down the best FREE dating app and website around. Everything is 100% free. Im reading these reviews of how some people never get replied to followed by them ranting about the site being fake. Well I hate to say this but there are other reasons no one is replying to those people lol. Sorry but it's the truth. I have personally received dozens of msg's from girls using plenty of fish. I am currently talking to one of these girls on my phone now. So unless the girl I'm talking with on my actual phone works for plenty of fish I'm pretty sure it's a real site lol. This girl also lives very close to me fyi. I don't like people knocking a site just because they don't get contacted. Had I read one of these ridiculous negative reviews I may of never tried plenty of fish. There are massive scandalous dating sites and apps out there that will take your money. This is a completely legit and free dating site. Give it a shot dont listen to these lies about it being fake.

DO NOT GIVE THEM ANY MONEY. THIS IS A FREE SITE. YOU ARE STUPID IF YOU PAY.

The website was decent to below average years ago, and I did talk to real people on it. There still are some real people that use the site; however, the site is on its last leg. The site has a decent layout and gives off a false image, but its sole purpose is to generate ad revenue. There are a litany of problems with this site.

1). The website brags about being FREE, but it asks for MONEY!
2). The are many fake profiles. They are blatantly obvious & appear automated, for instance fake profiles will be named in similar patterns such as Katie1843, Megan1123, Anne1345, & usually the false profiles have young good looking girls looking provocative and hardly wearing anything (This is done to get men to sign up) (Doing a reverse image search with tinyeye or Google usually confirms they are fake as well.
3). Emails are sent out from fake profiles saying they want to meet you! (Again, another thing to pull people on the site so POF can make ad revenue)
4). The matches are bogus, and are generated at random. (If you go to the matches page and hit REFRESH, it will give you a new random list of matches.)
5). Many users that complain, especially about the credibility of site, or its profiles or anything will get banned. (The fact the they get rid of users who raise eyebrows nearly proves they have something to hide.)
6. Duplicate accounts are not allowed, but there are numerous ones out there, and they are usually fake.