Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

GB
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow Bernadette S.
Unfollow Bernadette S.
Share Review
Report Review

Having been scammed on two dating sites now I think it fair to say that if you are 50 plus and using this site or any other, be very careful. Look out for 'highly intelligent men' who seem unable to punctuate sentences correctly, make comments such as 'it was nice' and use future tense eg: I will like to speak with you again' and ask for your number after the first conversation. Sadly, like the other site I was on, fake profiles seem to be in abundance. Tread with caution!

Date of experience: August 7, 2014
Georgia
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Michele B.
Unfollow Michele B.
Share Review
Report Review

I have a friend who just discovered that a member of this dating site has stolen her pictures off of her Facebook page and downloaded them to her profile! It is absolutely ridiculous that she cannot report this person for stealing her image and using it on this site, without signing up for the website! Plentyoffish needs to review their policy because my friend refuses to sign up for the website and give any of her information just to be able to report this woman! She goes by xoxo_nc Cary north carolina

Date of experience: August 3, 2014
California
4 reviews
34 helpful votes
Follow julie w.
Unfollow julie w.
Share Review
Report Review

I got very lucky
August 3, 2014

I got very lucky. I met a few decent men who were local to me and am still in contact with them on and off. I also met a good match for me a year ago last March and we have been seeing each other for the last 16 months and very happy. Our Time is a terrible site -make sure you search for reviews before spending time there. Match.com had a lot more foreign scammers than POF, imo.

Date of experience: August 3, 2014
Florida
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Marisa T.
Unfollow Marisa T.
Share Review
Report Review

By far the WORST dating app I've ever been on... I had to make a new account about 3 times because they kept DELETING IT! I'm surprised it even has people going on it at all. Worst worst worst app I cannot stress to you enough. Use any other dating app and you will be happier than if you used pof. Honesty it horrible

Date of experience: July 29, 2014
Arkansas
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow mary c.
Unfollow mary c.
Share Review
Report Review

I went on dates with two men that I met on POF. The first date was awful because the guy just wanted 2 things: Sex and watching cartoons! The second man I went on a date with was wonderful! We dated for two years and he is the love of my life! I married him earlier this year! POF was free for me to join and communicate with people and I think that it is a plus! I would recommend it to anyone!

Date of experience: July 27, 2014
Louisiana
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow Dan K.
Unfollow Dan K.
Share Review
Report Review

I was surprised to see so many people had the same experience as I had with POF. Tried twice to use this site and both times my profile was deleted for no reason and no explanation. Didn't do anything against their terms of service. One was deleted after one week and the other was deleted after two days. I don't consider this a legitimate dating site. Just goes to show that nothing is free...

Date of experience: July 26, 2014
North Carolina
1 review
32 helpful votes
Follow Jai P.
Unfollow Jai P.
Share Review
Report Review

This website is gender biased. Women can send private pics, but men cannot. How ironic that all i see on their pics is cleavage and butt shots. I assumed if you're providing a service, all aspects of that service were to be available to all consumers. Not the case here. Also, anyone can report you and your account will be removed or blocked. Mostly men are the victims. I read a few reviews about this, but until it recently happened to me, I was skeptical. Avoid this site

Date of experience: July 23, 2014
GB
3 reviews
9 helpful votes
Follow CC P.
Unfollow CC P.
Share Review
Report Review

Depends what your looking for. 5 stars if you want to meet people who just want a bit on the side and nothing serious. If you looking for a casual no strings thing this is the place but those seeking a proper relationship should avoid.

Date of experience: July 21, 2014
New York
9 reviews
25 helpful votes
Follow Leith R.
Unfollow Leith R.
Share Review
Report Review

A decent dating site. You can message for free, view for free, everything is actually free. The people on pof seem a little lower quality than, say, OKCupid, and the site isn't nearly as snazzy in terms of interface. But it does what it says on the tin.

Date of experience: July 15, 2014
Washington
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Corey B.
Unfollow Corey B.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of fish was a blessing to me! Its all about first impressions. I started online in 2009 I messaged 3 woman and one responded and I knew her! So we talked for a couple weeks, I took her out then and since then 5 yrs later I married her! Our conversation and honesty got us this far. We have a child together and we love each other unconditionally!

Date of experience: July 13, 2014
California
1 review
17 helpful votes
Follow Jerry H.
Unfollow Jerry H.
Share Review
Report Review

Pof is a scam it's not free as it claims, you have to pay to use half of the services and it's full of webcam girls, hookers, escorts, and scam artists. I'd never recommend this sight to anyone.

Date of experience: July 12, 2014
Kentucky
1 review
32 helpful votes
Follow Brandon M.
Unfollow Brandon M.
Share Review
Report Review

I will never ever use this website again! It is full of crackpots, losers and hopeless alcoholics who are loo king to clean up someone elses leftovers out of desperation. Theyre always looking to find someone to take pity on their sorry existences. I have learned thanks to the experiences Ive had with POF that going out on a date with someone really makes me appreciate being alone... and I love not having romantic love in my life!

Date of experience: July 12, 2014
Ohio
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Sun F.
Unfollow Sun F.
Share Review
Report Review

Actually this article doesnt cover the facts of POF. I have personally reported 3 sex offenders to the site through the complaint form. Which was completely ignored, except to delete my profiles. I provided evidence, and even the offenders families testimonies. These offenders also spread Gonorrhea, and it has become a health hazard for the community. Though in the male list of the site. I did meet two cops who are actively monitoring the site. None the less. Of all the sites I have looked into. Plenty of Fish is the only one actively protecting sexual offenders, and disease spreaders from the truth. The company of POF does not maintain their own rule in order to protect these individuals. This is the site to use, as a woman at least, if you want to be raped, infected with stds, and have attempted murder practiced upon you. I have screen shots of all that I claim with in this post. The site POF needs shut down, and the owners tried for the crimes they are knowingly allowing to occur via their site! To their members, and the community!

Date of experience: July 10, 2014
Canada
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Erline J.
Unfollow Erline J.
Share Review
Report Review

At first, I was intrigued. Love the free viewing & interactive opportunities with others. However, it's not clear to me where to go to get questions answered. Like for fitness, would you date someone with a few extra LBS? Or BBW? What the heck does this acronym stand for? I asked for Caucasian men, other ethnic show up & ppl way younger or older than the age bracket I requested. I chose MissPrissStl as my profile name. Edited profile on different issue, hit check Mark at top right & after all I went through to get this site to remove my real name, my username, ErlineJinesSchneider, correcting name chosen for my profile, it's now showing my real name again which concerns me as I said before when they corrected. Very frustrating!

Date of experience: July 9, 2014
Virginia
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Glen B.
Unfollow Glen B.
Share Review
Report Review

I am been on Plenty of Fish for a while now. The truth is, as far as sites go,
POF is really good. The site works well, filters are very good, and follow up
Are excellent. Yes I have meet a few women on this site. What is my conclusion?
They want only two things. A free, expensive meal and an endless supply of
Batteries for their vibrators. Supply both, and your in. Good luck Guys. Glen

Date of experience: July 9, 2014
Canada
2 reviews
32 helpful votes
Follow Jack S.
Unfollow Jack S.
Share Review
Report Review

Complete bull$#*!
July 7, 2014

Complete bull$#*!. Markus is an ugly loser who obviously has issues. Sorry how you look Markus, and sorry you have a small $#*!. My profile got deleted because after getting my greeting message from Markus, I replied to him. I said. Markus, don't you think it is a little arrogant to list yourself as the "Creator"... the only creator is God. Bam delete! Markus you are an arrogant Nazi, $#*!. You are a creepy weirdo that thinks he has to protect every woman on this site. We are adults. We do not need you telling us who we can connect with, what age we can connect with and what we say in our "private" messages. If an "adult" woman dislikes a message she can simply block that individual. Markus you are a scammer and a fraud. You knowingly post fake profiles and then ask men to pay! You advertise a free site... and then if anyone actually wants to chat they have to pay you. I can go on all day but you're not worth it. Good luck when you get busted for the fraud that you are. $#*!!

Date of experience: July 7, 2014
Ohio
1 review
30 helpful votes
Follow Darryl B.
Unfollow Darryl B.
Share Review
Report Review

My experience on Pof has been just as bad as a lot of the men in there most wemen are on there to get money, and you get banded for no good reason you try to be respectful and nice to people and follow all the rules but u get banded like I did for no reason. Marcus your nothing but a complete $#*! hole and I would not care to say that to your face, you don't band people for no apparent reason, and say you got a really good site, and trust me I would not care one bit to tell you my users name that was on there you friggen twit, Guys don't spend on money on this site because ur just wasting your time and money

Date of experience: July 6, 2014
New Jersey
1 review
24 helpful votes
Follow Bruce D.
Unfollow Bruce D.
Share Review
Report Review

POF and Marcus along with his staff are nothing but a bunch of religious fanatic anti-male Canadian $#*! holes. They block people for absolutely no reason. I should not say people it is men they do this to. This is done for absolutely no reason. Anyone can make a complaint and they will disable your profile and not answer an email. They will not even tell you you have been blocked. He is anti-sexual and a total control freak. His staff will not reply when you ask them politely why or even if you were blocked. They blocked me for absolutely no reason whatsoever. I was never rude or used any language that was inappropriate. I have written them multiple times and asked them why I'm being blocked they never answered me. If there were another site both myself And others would use it.

Date of experience: July 1, 2014
Australia
2 reviews
21 helpful votes
Follow Matt L.
Unfollow Matt L.
Share Review
Report Review

I was on pof for two weeks.
I seen many fake profile with fake locations.
I was nice, I thought it was not to bad considering it's free but then my account was deleted with absolute no explanation.

Date of experience: June 30, 2014
Florida
3 reviews
53 helpful votes
Follow moe k.
Unfollow moe k.
Share Review
Report Review

Mostly women who are there just to assist if they still have it to attract men! Huge number of saddest women who enjoy putting men down who think all men are the same! One size fits all because they had one bad experience for their ignorance! Most women are looking for a perfect man but they have nothing to bring to the table!, mostly snobs, insecure, ugly, fearful, misfits, dating sites addicts, amazingly seductive women but in no way they are ready to meet any one rather have a relation! Just plain time wasters,, they never tell the truth about intention or age unless they a re not ready to date and do not care! They should call it
" PLENTY OF FAKE "
"

Date of experience: June 27, 2014