Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Illinois
7 reviews
23 helpful votes
Follow Jana R.
Unfollow Jana R.
Share Review
Report Review

Lots of weird people
September 6, 2015

I have heard the most awkward things in this website. I was using their app. There are ridiculous amount of weirdos, that can talk about nothing but sex. Definitely not a dating website. More like tinder now.

Date of experience: September 6, 2015
GB
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Nikki d.
Unfollow Nikki d.
Share Review
Report Review

Fake
September 6, 2015

Anyone talking to breathiffreshair100 he is a fake, the photos he has used are of a famous American baseball player. Stay clear as there is something dodgy about him

Date of experience: September 6, 2015
Florida
11 reviews
46 helpful votes
Follow Michael G.
Unfollow Michael G.
Share Review
Report Review

Met a girl on there.
September 6, 2015

Original post-
Thangs are goin alright like her alot she comes over every night. Good site.

*EDIT*

One year and 2 months later...

It didn't work out with me and the girl. But that's because I went to jail and she just wanted to be negative while i was in there and couldn't deal with it. The site is still really good, I've met a few other people on there. Never any real Creepers or Weirdos. But I am a Male so I am not sure how great it is for females. Haha.

Date of experience: September 5, 2015
Texas
1 review
51 helpful votes
Follow Sara L.
Unfollow Sara L.
Share Review
Report Review

Bias
September 5, 2015

Very bias, they also racially profile. Don't waste money and pay for this $#*!

Date of experience: September 4, 2015
Minnesota
1 review
14 helpful votes
Follow Kelly D.
Unfollow Kelly D.
Share Review
Report Review

Horrible
September 4, 2015

The guys are looking for an easy hookup. As a female on the site on and off for 3 years. Guys are pigs and liars and pof has features that, if you want, you have to pay extra money for. If you're female looking for a good time, this site is for you. If you're female looking for someone special, look elsewhere. I'm a female, 48, self sufficient, 5'4" 138 Lbs with a great personality. I'm outta here!

Date of experience: September 4, 2015
Texas
1 review
17 helpful votes
Follow Bobby S.
Unfollow Bobby S.
Share Review
Report Review

Beware!
September 3, 2015

There are already plenty of reviews here describing the type of people you will meet on POF, if you meet any, but that's not what I am here for. I purchased an upgraded membership, which doesn't give you much more than being able to see when the last time a person was online and their "extended profile" if they have completed a couple of personal surveys. My complaint is that there is no way on their site to stop the auto renew charge to your account. I used their internal email, which is the only way to contact them because the customer service number always gives a busy signal.

I sent an email requesting my membership be downgraded back to the free membership. I did not receive a reply so I completely deleted my profile. I received an email, in my spam file a few days later stating I had been charged through the auto renew. I attempted to contact their customer service, but the line is always busy. I read the email and saw that if you Paypal for your payment, you could go to their site and cancel the auto renew and end future payments. Thank God I used Paypal.

I called Paypal and described the situation. The customer service agent was awesome. She cancelled any future charges and captured the funds for the most recent unauthorized charge. It will take a few days for me to see it in my Paypal account, but that's fine. I will never return to that site and I advise you to stay away from it too.

Date of experience: September 3, 2015
Michigan
1 review
30 helpful votes
Follow Candy S.
Unfollow Candy S.
Share Review
Report Review

Carolyn Jones from Wayne, Michigan scammed my son out of over $35,000.00 by having him opening up credit cards and sending the bills to her address and putting her name on his checking.
While promising my son how she wanted him to move in with her and it never happened. Beware of the people you meet on this site.

Date of experience: September 3, 2015
GB
1 review
7 helpful votes
Follow john t.
Unfollow john t.
Share Review
Report Review

Been on three weeks paid up for two months sent message got no reply some of them had not been on line for two months but there profile was still up to read and message them went on yesterday clicked on my profile yesterday and it said your account has been deleted no message why ore how am still waiting for a reply from customers services witch is a automated service so the have robbed five weeks worth of money from me?

Date of experience: September 2, 2015
Pennsylvania
1 review
17 helpful votes
Follow Kyle T.
Unfollow Kyle T.
Share Review
Report Review

I have been on this site for a while now. I have sent too many messages to count and almost all of them have either just read them and not responded, or they delete them without responding. Most of the women are just in it for a hook up or they just all out don't want a relationship of any kind.

Date of experience: September 2, 2015
Illinois
1 review
42 helpful votes
Follow Roger M.
Unfollow Roger M.
Share Review
Report Review

Don't bother with it I lost just 3 months subscription. This is the worst web site I have ever been on

Date of experience: August 31, 2015
Virginia
1 review
61 helpful votes
Follow David W.
Unfollow David W.
Share Review
Report Review

Would be nice if...
August 31, 2015

I would have to say the site itself is not so bad, it is easy to use and stuff, but the real problem is in with the people that have joined the site... I know with what I am about to say you will probably roll your eyes and say who doesn't do that but everyone on there just lies about them self an example is they will say they are super friendly and down to earth... I know I have messaged quite a few people and I have the upgraded membership so I can see this, people just delete your messages without even reading them... whats the point in that? How do you get to know someone if they or you never bother to read it?! I would have to say this site is totally toxic and if you want to feel bad for yourself feel free to join up and be disappointed like I am. I know I wont renew my membership when it expires.

Date of experience: August 31, 2015
Florida
2 reviews
71 helpful votes
Follow Joe B.
Unfollow Joe B.
Share Review
Report Review

This website is nothing more than a tool for CRIMINALS to scam victims $. I have filed an FBI complaint against this site.

Date of experience: August 31, 2015
Pennsylvania
2 reviews
17 helpful votes
Follow Kimberly G.
Unfollow Kimberly G.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of frauds
August 29, 2015

Been on and off this site for a few years. I've concluded that the majority of the men I met and dated had mental problems. They aren't who they said they were. Seems like these days ppl are looking for hookups and want to play head games. Im an adult. I have no time for men children.

Date of experience: August 29, 2015
Texas
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow May T.
Unfollow May T.
Share Review
Report Review

How to do POF...
August 27, 2015

I'm not sure why are you all so disappointed and toxic. You get what you seek. When making your profile, you need to define your core values. You need to be able to express yourself. Also, when it comes to choosing a life partner you can't be clueless about what you really want and need. You shouldn't post explicit photos of yourself and expect to be treated respectfully (unfortunately, that's how life is), or try to get match with the people who are not compatible to you or your lifestyle.

The best thing you can do is to be yourself. Only then you have a chance to find a true mach... and love...

Just my two cents... :)

Date of experience: August 25, 2015
Pennsylvania
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow Cindie W.
Unfollow Cindie W.
Share Review
Report Review

I realize it is not ALL men... but what DECENT guy would want to sleep with a female without really knowing anything about her... especially her health history? If a man (or woman) has no concern about their own health, what makes you think they would care about yours? I don't "hookup", and don't want to be involved with anyone who does... and you find those types of men (and the ones with criminal records), aplenty on this site.

Date of experience: August 25, 2015
Washington
2 reviews
49 helpful votes
Follow Robert B.
Unfollow Robert B.
Share Review
Report Review

Exposing Frauds
August 24, 2015

I have had one response &it seems nobody has read my profile on both sides. They don't pay attention to my preferences and get bad mix of age, localeðnicity. Also unauthorised credit card withdrawals with no notifications.Are these women real then why the "canned" responses. I am totally disgusted and buyer beware!

Date of experience: August 24, 2015
Pennsylvania
1 review
42 helpful votes
Follow Steve F.
Unfollow Steve F.
Share Review
Report Review

POF Chances are
August 22, 2015

Yeah this site is actually not ran on a bad hosting but it makes you wonder. I look at profiles and wonder sometimes if it is a real one or not. Very simply be honest. I have a better chance of being with a guy than a girl. Weird isn't it.

Date of experience: August 21, 2015
District of Columbia
2 reviews
13 helpful votes
Follow M m.
Unfollow M m.
Share Review
Report Review

Tell the truth, post a recent flattering picture and women who have things in common with you will respond. The negativity on many of these posts is from men (and women) who simply are not ready to meet their counterparts on POF. Don't expect replies to inadequate profiles or expect others to buy a pig in a poke (no picture.) Human nature is what it is and society has trained us over the past 30 years that it is important to reel in someone who is attractive. If you don't write in an appealing way and post an appealing picture, guess what, you're not going to get replies from prince charming or princess Leah

Date of experience: August 20, 2015
California
2 reviews
8 helpful votes
Follow Marie B.
Unfollow Marie B.
Share Review
Report Review

I don't know why guys feel the need to do this, but pof don't allow it
However, women may share private images.

Date of experience: August 20, 2015
Massachusetts
2 reviews
40 helpful votes
Follow Claire S.
Unfollow Claire S.
Share Review
Report Review

Useless waste of time
August 18, 2015

There are two types of men here. Men who have personality disorders or guys who are waiting for Miss America to contact them. They dont have the courtesy to respond but just ignore messages. Oh wait there is a third category- men who pretend to want to meet but disappear as soon as you ask to get together. I did meet one guy who proceeded to tell me on the first date the rules of our new life together and what type of sex we would be having. I won't mention that he was going to instruct me on proper bowel movements during dinner. You can't make this stuff up!

Date of experience: August 17, 2015