Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Ireland
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Tangela G.
Unfollow Tangela G.
Share Review
Report Review

Awful
January 2, 2016

Chatted and texted with a guy for 5 months and we never met.

Date of experience: January 2, 2016
GB
1 review
16 helpful votes
Follow Jennifer P.
Unfollow Jennifer P.
Share Review
Report Review

I have been on this site a couple of times. The first time a couple of years agowas ok and I met a few genuine men, although there was a sleazy element.

My experience this time round however is completely different. This site has now become a forum for sexual grooming. There are many attractive, articulate, well educated men on this site with excellent profiles saying that they are seeking a relationship but when you dig a little deeper or have a few dates with them you realise that they are grooming women for sexual purposes.

I rarely write reviews but I feel emotionally drained and feel that unsuspecting women are very vulnerable on this site. I just want to warn other ladies what they are up against.

Date of experience: January 2, 2016
Washington
2 reviews
12 helpful votes
Follow your m.
Unfollow your m.
Share Review
Report Review

I've met a handful of awesome guys and boat loads of chumps (yes in person). The interesting ones never wanted to commit longer than a few months; from my experience they never deleted their accounts (or stopped talking to their exs)after we'd meet, and continued to communicate with other "fish" while we were in the pre commitment phase. Ultimately each one found someone else. The chumps... well at least I have hilarious stories to tell. I believe when there is so much to choose from people tend to find it easier not to make a serious decision at all.

Date of experience: January 1, 2016
GB
1 review
79 helpful votes
Follow jason d.
Unfollow jason d.
Share Review
Report Review

What a fukn joke
December 31, 2015

1/100 messages sent say hi to women were completely ignored, the one girl started talking but then stopped when I got serious about asking what her main goal/hobby is, fuk that pissed me off badly I almost broke my phone then pissed my dad off about how women don't have a clue what a real man is ect. He did agree btw a real man want love not a quick std, I hate being ignored especially 99 times with sluts I mean girls that don't reply to a happy new year message or how are you, I did have two women that approached me first but they were larger then life so I messaged them back saying thank you for noticing me but I don't think we are matched good luck x, the way I was raised was to be polite and friendly, what a bunch of no life sluts on there, I'm glad no one responded as Im way to big of a catch for them to handle. Pof kiss my $#*!

Date of experience: December 31, 2015
California
7 reviews
107 helpful votes
Follow Court D.
Unfollow Court D.
Share Review
Report Review

Horrible!
December 31, 2015

I decided to try POF to possibly start a serious relationship. Bad idea! Most of the guys on there are looking for a one night stand. A lot of the messages I got were from horny guys asking if I wanted "D" pics and trying to meet up for sex. I even wrote on my profile that I'm not interested in sex until marriage, but I guess they think I'll make an exception for them. I even got blocked by a guy because I told him I wasn't going to do foreplay with him. Even when you look at their bios most of the guys say they're not looking to commit. That's because they just wanna sleep with you! There were even men looking for women to have threesomes with. The rest of the profiles that sound too good to be true, usually are.

Date of experience: December 30, 2015
California
1 review
22 helpful votes
Follow LISA G.
Unfollow LISA G.
Share Review
Report Review

Waste of time people don't want anything just sex, they get your number wanna Tex all day an still be online, it's one in a million you will find someone decent... good look

Date of experience: December 27, 2015
Colorado
4 reviews
92 helpful votes
Follow phil c.
Unfollow phil c.
Share Review
Report Review

Going to hell would be like being a male perpetually stuck on POF begging ladies for a chance to possibly meet them so you could apologize for not being young enough, tall enough, wealthy enough, powerful enough, good enough dancer, golfer, or anything else that each one of them are entitled to have chase after them.
I do not have anything against the site itself. What I do not understand is through life, ladies i have encountered in so many aspects of life, treat me with respect and general courtesy. Why then on POF am I ignored, deceived, lied to, by profiles that state they are thoughtful, sincere, and want the same in a man. I'd love to get fortunate and turn my back on this crappy experience of just never being good enough for the princesses of POF.

Date of experience: December 26, 2015
North Carolina
1 review
75 helpful votes
Follow Matt A.
Unfollow Matt A.
Share Review
Report Review

Worthless
December 24, 2015

This site is full of stuck up jaded women who thrive off of attention. Do not waste your time with a dating website like this you will get nowhere.

Date of experience: December 24, 2015
Ukraine
114 reviews
1650 helpful votes
Follow Justin T.
Unfollow Justin T.
Share Review
Report Review

Acceptable
December 23, 2015

It's free, easy to use and has a lot of people there.
But you can't really expect to find anyone decent there because most people just joined this site for trolling and attention-seeking.

Date of experience: December 23, 2015
GB
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Michael A.
Unfollow Michael A.
Share Review
Report Review

Sadly confusing?
December 22, 2015

Hi yes I have a very unpleasant question?
I originally paid £39/99 which according to my bank account was taken by FESTIVUS name unknown to me. And within a short few hours after that ' someone' took a further £ 51 GB POUNDS AND ALSO ANOTHER PAYMENT OF £7/99? PAY PAL took the 51 amount and a name unknown to me took 39/99 and the 7/99 separately in addition to my initial payment of 39/99? All this results for me in 3 big red flags of something not right? Therefore, albeit your site seems fair and well organised, something is seriously amiss here regarding 2 additional, non authorised by me payments.
I have now informed my bank and they are looking into all these 3 payments due to confusing payments with names and 2 unauthorised payments! The only payment I did authorise was for 39/99 and my bank advised disputing that one also, due to incorrect name of recipient of payment! So,
Please inform me of any new information you discover re this confusion. Thanks Merry Christmas, Michael...

Date of experience: December 22, 2015
Texas
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow Dave C.
Unfollow Dave C.
Share Review
Report Review

Pathetic
December 22, 2015

All kinds of picture of women flipping the middle finger, I have had women get mad because I don't respond. I'M AT WORK, I HAVE A JOB. Women pretty damn close to nude
But if men do anything like that they get deleted in a heart beat. Not sure who runs this site but pretty weird if you ask me.

Date of experience: December 21, 2015
South Africa
2 reviews
8 helpful votes
Follow mike w.
Unfollow mike w.
Share Review
Report Review

pof.com
December 20, 2015

It is the most difficult site to register on Keeps on chucking me out sending me in circles to fix things, wouldn't accept any usernames I fed it!

Date of experience: December 20, 2015
California
1 review
24 helpful votes
Follow Lovinlife H.
Unfollow Lovinlife H.
Share Review
Report Review

This dating site seems to be filled with fakes. Not only have I experienced this, but also others I have spoken with. They usually start out, "looking for a relationship " when in reality they are looking to hook up with no serious intentions. Beware the "sucessful", handsome, athletic (Aka, gym rat), who drives a luxury vehicle. There is a reason a 40 something year old man (never married) is on dating sites. NEVER MARRIED, big red flag. Why do you think that is?!? Um, can you say, "personality disorder?" Haha. Scary.

Date of experience: December 16, 2015
Switzerland
3 reviews
21 helpful votes
Follow Erica P.
Unfollow Erica P.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammers Paradise!
December 16, 2015

I was attracted to the "zero tollerance policy" against married users, under-age, scammers, nudity, overtly sexual approaches etc... it seemed to guarantee a higher standard of user and provide some safeguards against scammers... I paid for an upgraded account, but I was disappointed... Fake profiles... Scammers... Inactive profiles from 1947days!

It seems that the "zero tolerance policy" is self policing by the community with the "rate images" function the users are invited to approve or delete the photographs of other users, which suggests that they are not reviewed by POF at all... I don't know...

My main frustration was with customer support which is robotic and when eventually they do answer it is unhelpful. Queries about payments took 13 days to receive a standard response. They seem to have an automated response to all queries - the deletion of account and a refund... Very impersonal. No evidence of real people reading and responding to your query.

I reported a scammer, with evidence of real identity of person on the photo, This resulted in the deletion of my account!? Maybe the scammer realised that I had rumbled him and he had my profile deleted? That's ok! Saved me the trouble... LOL! I would not recommend the site all in all...

If you do use this site, I would recommend that when you like someone to move communication to email or chat because your or their account could disappear at any time!

Date of experience: December 16, 2015
Washington
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Mindy T.
Unfollow Mindy T.
Share Review
Report Review

"Be wary of fakes ladies"
December 16, 2015

This is not just one personal incident I have heard from others about how terrible POF. Some claim, "Looking for a relationship" when in fact they are looking to hook up with no serious relationship intentions. Look out for the good looking, gym rat, driving a luxury car, don't be fooled by that charm!
Ladies think about why a handsome older guy, NEVER married, is on a dating site... BIG RED FLAG. BEWARE. All I can say is yuk.

Date of experience: December 16, 2015
Louisiana
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Bill H.
Unfollow Bill H.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of BS!
December 16, 2015

I did nothing wrong now all of a sudden my pof is gone!

Date of experience: December 16, 2015
California
1 review
60 helpful votes
Follow chad j.
Unfollow chad j.
Share Review
Report Review

Absolutely horrible.
December 14, 2015

Plenty of fakes that's for sure. Shallow rude stuck up single mom's overweight. So many. Few decent girls on there get swamped with mssgs anyway and no guy seems to stand a chance. Don't waste your time like so many others have.

Date of experience: December 14, 2015
Florida
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow J J.
Unfollow J J.
Share Review
Report Review

Just like many reviews on here state, it's not a real dating site. Most men put that they're looking for a relationship but in reality they are looking for hookups. Some men have even lied about having children. What kind of person lies about their own children?! Disgusting. Even found out one user not only has a pof account claiming to be looking for a relationship but he also has a bunch of profiles on sex sites. Gross! Ladies beware of Misterme812. Keep a look out for these as well, MistermeOR, Misterme81, and Misterme8123. All the same person with multiple accounts.

Date of experience: December 8, 2015
Kansas
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Cathy A.
Unfollow Cathy A.
Share Review
Report Review

Worst customer service
December 8, 2015

I was charged for a 8th month membership even tho I signed up for 2. I asked for a refund of the difference. No response. Asked again. Said I would contact CCcompany if I needed to. 2 hours later my entire profile and still won't respond to emails.As bad as the rest of them.

Date of experience: December 7, 2015
South Carolina
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow A J.
Unfollow A J.
Share Review
Report Review

BEWARE if you upgrade!
December 7, 2015

I cancelled my subscription last month and they still automatically withdrew payment from my bank though no longer have an account nor can I access the site without re-registering. There is no way to actually contact these people either. I contacted the bank so this should not happen again but I was still ripped off by these people.

Date of experience: December 7, 2015