Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Colorado
1 review
34 helpful votes
Follow Gene S.
Unfollow Gene S.
Share Review
Report Review

I was a member of POF for over 10 years, never had a problem till lately when someone stole my identity there, my user name there was stargazers321 which the scammer now uses. He put a photo of himself and a blow up doll on my profile and used most of my info. Three times I hit the "Report User " button and three times my new account was deleted, now I was just deleted again after not even using the button so they have blocked my IPP address now. At first I thought it was the scammer deleting me but now I think its POF being stupid!

Date of experience: June 27, 2016
South Carolina
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Stephanie W.
Unfollow Stephanie W.
Share Review
Report Review

I've been on POF for about 5 months and have have alot dates. Alot of the men just want sex but was willing to wine and dine to do so. Had alot of good meals but no real connection. Alot of scumbags for sure but that's life. Some say they live near you when they really are contract workers and only visiting. Meet alot of guys that want you for an uber driver. Decided to give it one last try when I meet the love of my life. So it's not so bad just have to be mindful. Some people lie very well. Happy fishing.

Date of experience: June 27, 2016
France
2 reviews
35 helpful votes
Follow Brian A.
Unfollow Brian A.
Share Review
Report Review

TIME WASTER!
June 26, 2016

Pretty much perfect... if you like to waste your time!

Date of experience: June 26, 2016
Connecticut
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Melanie M.
Unfollow Melanie M.
Share Review
Report Review

It started with the type of payee POF set itself up as in my Paypal account. An automatic, self-renewing, payee. Once I realized what they had done I immediately removed them, but if I hadn't carefully read the emails I wouldn't have known. Then the made-up messages started coming in, when I responded to the first few I was met with huh? Or nothing, because those people had never messaged me. And the lurking men... Why not just get on a straight dating site? Honestly, my online POF experience has just made me feel like a loser. And, no refund.

Date of experience: June 25, 2016
Ohio
4 reviews
9 helpful votes
Follow eric s.
Unfollow eric s.
Share Review
Report Review

Rude
June 23, 2016

Most women on plenty of fish are excessively rude, and if a guy says a rude comment in response, the guy is deleted by the website, excessive aggressive behavior by the website, my advice is, go talk to people in retail stores

Date of experience: June 23, 2016
California
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Teresita M.
Unfollow Teresita M.
Share Review
Report Review

Horrible Experience
June 23, 2016

Please beware of heavenlysent7- aka David Griggs Bickler. This guy was phony from the get-go. He lied by saying he's from San Mateo - which he's NOT. He preached about the perfect woman but yet his ideals are so far from reality... you have to program a robot to fulfill his desires because No Woman in their right mind would give this Creep the time of day... please beware and be safe!

Date of experience: June 22, 2016
Missouri
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Ron T.
Unfollow Ron T.
Share Review
Report Review

I got 2 women to respond to me they are the nice ones

Date of experience: June 21, 2016
Canada
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Inderjit k.
Unfollow Inderjit k.
Share Review
Report Review

I don't know what the hell happened, and how they get my credit card number. I get this msg from a POF user (POF_billing) which says I am being charged with $43.67. I am *******% sure that I never upgraded POF service... This is wired. I am still wondering how they get my credit card number. I email POF for refund now Let's see what happens next

Date of experience: June 21, 2016
GB
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow graham s.
Unfollow graham s.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of Fakes
June 21, 2016

I was on POF for over a year and had a few dates out of it. But most of the women on there are just after a free lunch.
Very Rude people who don't actually want to genuinely settle down and form a relationship.
Then eventually POF shut down my account without notice. No reason given?
AVOID
Bad site, Bad members, Bad company

Date of experience: June 21, 2016
Texas
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Ann B.
Unfollow Ann B.
Share Review
Report Review

POF Dating Scam
June 21, 2016

Beware profile *******@gmail as well as pof address, Haggard Antonio Gardner are names used on the pof site. This profile user stated he was US Military and wanted items sent to him. Pulled his profile as soon as he could after contact. When asked about his military email and proof of who he was, he began saying he wasn't forcing anyone and stopped contact. Customer service at this site has been reviewed as useless, so I chose this way to inform those Interested in the type of activity on the site. The FBI and FTC can also be contacted if you are aware of scams.

Date of experience: June 21, 2016
Pennsylvania
1 review
48 helpful votes
Follow mike s.
Unfollow mike s.
Share Review
Report Review

PURE GARBAGE!
If you are looking for serious relationship with a good and normal woman then avoid this site!
1) lots of fake profiles from scammers
2) lots of hookers on the site
3) women with mental problems
4) women just playing games and don't want to meet in person, when you ask for a phone number after a conversation they block you
5) women on this site have profiles for years, one girl said to me that she is on POF for 8 years.
6) If you don't have a photo in your profile, very rarely you will get a response as your message will get deleted without being read or just ignored.
7) If you have a photo in your profile and don't look like a movie star, same as above.
8) average looking women at best, think of themselves that they are movie stars, some with no picture in their profile won't allow you to email them without a picture in your profile.
9) lots of gold diggers, looking for a fat wallet to support them and their newborns from a previous relationship.

Date of experience: June 19, 2016
GB
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Daniel M.
Unfollow Daniel M.
Share Review
Report Review

The amount of times I've messaged girls and they delete your messages without even reading them or viewing your profile, it's full of attention seeking slags who just want as much male attention as possible.

Date of experience: June 17, 2016
Pennsylvania
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Jayne D.
Unfollow Jayne D.
Share Review
Report Review

This site needs a tech tune up! It constantly deletes my profile after 10 mins. Deletes messages and information. Encrypted messages/symbols or whatever. If I could give no stars it still wouldn't be satisfying.

Date of experience: June 16, 2016
Thailand
1 review
32 helpful votes
Follow Dick H.
Unfollow Dick H.
Share Review
Report Review

I tried this site for several months. Not worth the time, money or effort.
Many fake and outdated profiles that keep showing up.
A lot of scammers wanting business.
Too many fat women.
Also too many restrictions. The age restriction was the killer for me.
Much better sites out there.

Date of experience: June 15, 2016
Idaho
1 review
25 helpful votes
Follow Steven S.
Unfollow Steven S.
Share Review
Report Review

Garbage
June 16, 2016

I had my Upgraded account Hacked 2 days ago, profile photo changed, everything, have sent countless E Mails to the Support, even turned my hacked account in, with ZERO response from anyone

Date of experience: June 15, 2016
Florida
5 reviews
29 helpful votes
Follow Marius P.
Unfollow Marius P.
Share Review
Report Review

It's not like common swipe apps or Facebook. So I think people have unrealistic expectations of the site. I thought it was decent at what it intended to do. Unfortunately the site is really bloated and slow at times. I wish it was more streamlined and flexible for users. Lastly, I'm not fond of how difficult it is to completely remove your information.

Date of experience: June 11, 2016
Canada
1 review
7 helpful votes
Follow Krista B.
Unfollow Krista B.
Share Review
Report Review

Harassment!
June 9, 2016

I have just emailed customer care for the THIRD time requesting that they stop sending me match emails as I deleted my account OVER A YEAR AGO and they have not responded to any of my emails. I just sent them an email on Monday requesting that they stop and not only did I not get a response, but I got yet ANOTHER match email TODAY!
Be warned if you sign up with them, even if you delete your account, they will ignore you and continue HARASSING you with emails for years! Even if you tell them you're getting married in a couple months, THEY WILL IGNORE YOU AND WILL NOT STOP!

Date of experience: June 9, 2016
Virginia
1 review
33 helpful votes
Follow Sally M.
Unfollow Sally M.
Share Review
Report Review

Was assaulted by someone on the site. When I tried to notify POF I was threatened. Not only will they ignore complaints about another user, you can get yourself kicked off their site for reporting it. Their policies put all women in danger and should be shut down.

Note to all men: taking a woman to dinner or listening to her talk does not give you rights to her body. Most prostitutes charge much more than that.

Forcing yourself on a woman hoping she can't get away from you IS assault.

Date of experience: June 5, 2016
Washington
1 review
26 helpful votes
Follow Jon s.
Unfollow Jon s.
Share Review
Report Review

POF! Scumbags!#
June 4, 2016

Connecticut pof women are lowlife scum. They constantly lie about their age looks job. Most of these women are lowlife gutterrats looking for a sugardaddy. They are fat ugly obese farm animals.the women from fairfield county are 2 doolar who**s looking for men of donald trump status. Piss on them. They all suck!

Date of experience: June 4, 2016
Canada
1 review
34 helpful votes
Follow Curtis S.
Unfollow Curtis S.
Share Review
Report Review

I had a one-hour conversation with a girl last night she said she was off to be so I said by then I ask her out I didn't get a response but she's online so I send her some spam message to see if I can get her attention nothing... I'm starting to think that this site is rigged for us guys to fall at finding a date and that resorts back to meet me

Date of experience: May 31, 2016