Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

California
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow Anonymous a.
Unfollow Anonymous a.
Share Review
Report Review

Stormchaser1993 is Cheater and a lyer
He comes off so sweet, says he's a Christian and loves the lord, but I swear he won't show any real interest in you but sex right after I gave him my number. He told me he deleted his pof but was still on there a lot when we were together, something was very off about him but I wanted to believe he was a good guy so I stayed with him longer but I could not take all the conversations bout sex and my looks. So I broke up with him. I got no reply back and that's odd for someone who was talking to me bout kids and building a family. He's still on pof fishing :/

Date of experience: November 29, 2016
Washington
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Christian u.
Unfollow Christian u.
Share Review
Report Review

Today I got married
November 30, 2016

A year and a half maybe a little more ago I met my husband on POF. He messaged me a month or two before I got back to him but once I did we spoke for two weeks and each day he peaked my interest more. On June 22nd 2015 he came to visit me we met at a motel six and did what you'd expect anyone to do in a motel room for six hours. The next day I never expected to hear from again but god knows I wanted to so I texted him even though I swore to myself I wouldn't. That whole week he spent 700 dollars to say in my town with me because he didn't want to leave me. Needless to say we have been together ever since we have had our ups and downs but he is my best friend and now I'm not sure what I'd do without him.

Date of experience: November 28, 2016
Canada
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Jamila F.
Unfollow Jamila F.
Share Review
Report Review

WORST
November 28, 2016

First of all, this site/app does not deserve any star ratings. This is the worst dating app/website ever! There is no other option of what you exactly want as the options is so programmed, so I added what I exactly want under "About Me" section. And Guess what? Men whore around asking me for friends with benefit, and all the $#*!ing sexual desires they want. This is not a real dating site, instead, it is a $#*!ing dating site where men ask u to $#*! them. So? I suggest that they should add an option of "F-u-c-k-ing around" or "Just want to whore around looking for b-i-t-c-hess that I can f-u-c-k" Something like that, all men are $#*!ing ridiculous and too much prostitution going on, Men prostitute themselves and get girls for free. God! I pray that girls will be careful in dating these men. There is also another man who said he will pay money to $#*! him. Haha! This is the worst dating app ever! Please don't even dare download, also, Money ripped off huh? Trying to force u to upgrade so u can see who wants to meet u in person. Ridiculous! And Nasty! What is happening to our world seriously? It's getting disgusting, they don't care if they get HIV or something until they get it in actual. LOL. Men whoring should be the title of this app. The provider and owner of this site should have access and see conversation or something like a police job and delete accounts who abuse the site.

Date of experience: November 27, 2016
Canada
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Kim P.
Unfollow Kim P.
Share Review
Report Review

Full of cat-fishing men. In a 1 month period I had 1 legit response and 2 where they copied and pasted directly from the web and expected me to go along with it. Thank god I have good common sense and blocked them quick.

Date of experience: November 27, 2016
New Jersey
9 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Chad W.
Unfollow Chad W.
Share Review
Report Review

Good
January 18, 2021

I found here a lot of interesting people to communicate with. With some of them I still meet and spend great time!
If you want to find friend, come to POF

Date of experience: November 25, 2016
GB
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow Jake s.
Unfollow Jake s.
Share Review
Report Review

What a load of $#*!e
November 25, 2016

Full of attention seeking women. Most of them are there to waste time. If you're lucky enough to get a reply the majority of them just want to gossip and will eventually get bored with talking to you. I gave it 2 stars as I was lucky enough to go on a date with someone and she was ok. The date lasted 4 hours and she expected me to talk constantly for all that time. The first couple of hours went ok, we had a lot to talk about and then the conversation went dead who the $#*! can talk constantly for four hours? I've now met someone no thanks to pof. Guys don't waste your time full of stuck up women.

Date of experience: November 24, 2016
Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow John G.
Unfollow John G.
Share Review
Report Review

Lack of Customer Service
November 23, 2016

Received suggestion for POF Account upgrade, upgraded and been locked out since, my username and password longer works, POF states that my email address is not registered to an account (when I am 100% certain it is) and there is some other dude using my scree-name. Tried contacting Customer Service, but there is none, have sent emails and received only automated responses which were useless. This is so unfortunate because I am actually a paying continued customer of more than 1 year.

Date of experience: November 23, 2016
Canada
33 reviews
102 helpful votes
Follow Review F.
Unfollow Review F.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of Fakes
November 21, 2016

Catfish central! Very few real people on that site. The longer you are on it the more crap you have to deal with. People use it as their own way of getting revenge on people they don't like or people that wouldn't date them or broke up with them. Pathetic people try to exploit anyone who is legitimately looking for some kind of relationship.

Date of experience: November 21, 2016
Canada
1 review
13 helpful votes
Follow Doug C.
Unfollow Doug C.
Share Review
Report Review

Sue me, $#*!!
November 21, 2016

POF is pretty much useless. Anybody who is on POF for the right reasons gets drowned out by all of the other idiots. There are plenty of women on here who can be called "losers" (that's what they should really call this site). First of all, you have your single mothers, some with multiple kids. And where is the father, and in some cases fathers, to these children? Unless these men are deceased, why aren't they raising their kids? Seems to me that these women are looking for father figures for their kids. And then you have women who say they have bachelors degrees when all they really have is maybe a high school diploma. They must say that to try to attract educated guys. And then you also have women in their early to mid- thirties who say their students. What they're really saying is that they're unemployed or that they have a $#*!ty menial minimum wage job that they hate. It's possible that they could be going to school. Most likely a part-time evening college course. But who knows? Don't forget the single mothers who say family is important to them. Their probably trying to make it on their own but stay connected to mommy and daddy. They may even be living with their parents from time to time. Sounds like a double standard. A guy gets slammed for "living in mom's basement", but these women get off light just because their women. You also have women who are on here purely for entertainment purposes. They have no intention of actually dating. Don't even get me started on the fake profiles and scammers, or the fact that POF is anti-male. I'm not saying that women don't have a hard time on here, They do. It's just that men have to deal with a lot of bull$#*! too.

Date of experience: November 21, 2016
GB
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow David J.
Unfollow David J.
Share Review
Report Review

Rip off
November 16, 2016

Dont join POF... they cxl yr profile if you dont pay to upgrade... the profiles are five/ten years old. I joined 7years ago for a few weeks. Joined recently and same photos on there. The women dont exist. Be warned. Its a rip off. N the joker called Markus... is fake. Just wanted to warn others. Try badoo... real people on the not like plenty of fakes...

Date of experience: November 16, 2016
District of Columbia
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow Shaun J.
Unfollow Shaun J.
Share Review
Report Review

It sucks!
November 16, 2016

I was deleted after a week for no reason at all. I had no nude pics and never said anything bad to anyone. From what i heard this happens to people all the time. Stay clear of that garbage site!

Date of experience: November 16, 2016
GB
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Heather b.
Unfollow Heather b.
Share Review
Report Review

After a few absurd messages from some clearly diluded individuals. I actaully met the woman I'm now marrying on the 28th of December this year. This site was perfect for us. i highly recommend it. So thanks pof. For finding me my wife

Date of experience: November 12, 2016
GB
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow c b.
Unfollow c b.
Share Review
Report Review

JUST RUBBISH
November 8, 2016

The programmers have updated something and SCREWED it big time. Twice it logs out for no reason and blocks you - WHY it then just does not send you the link to reset password UT UTTER UTTER RUBBISH. I cannot say how bad the new site is

Date of experience: November 8, 2016
Ohio
3 reviews
20 helpful votes
Follow T s.
Unfollow T s.
Share Review
Report Review

In most cases we are rating the people on the site rather than the site itself. The site is clunky and outdated but you can search, message, and retrieve messages so for free you cant really complain about that!

I think that I am at least an average looking 49 year old woman. I have a great job, own my home, stable children, a good home life, financially stable, friendly, and very active. I don't frequent the bars or into any drugs use. So with that said I do not believe that dating sites are going to be the way that I will meet a man who has a similar life style. So much of the online world is based on similar interests and life style but the infamous "I like the outdoors" and even more often I am seeing "ask me" in the profiles rather than someone taking a few minutes to actually put some thought into it is telling me that we are really just looking at the pictures... As an FYI, the "ask me" are to be avoided... just trust me on that!

I met 4 men in the past 2 months from this site. 4 out of 4 of them when I asked for a recent picture the time span ranged from 3 months old to several years. 3 out of 4 when we met I did not recognize from the pictures. Honestly my pictures are within the current month so I don't understand.

Scary interactions -
The guy who sent a picture with maybe 10 Rx bottles next to him and living in someone's basement. Created a new profile after I blocked him and contacted me again.

Another guy who's profile picture was so different from what he sent me on my phone and he didn't actually live in the state that he claimed got angry with me when I told him the his misrepresentation scared me and there was no way that I would want to meet him in person.

I respect the law and law enforcement so the next thing that I am going to mention is very bothersome. I chatted with 2 men in law enforcement that both asked for pictures that I was not comfortable with taking/sharing. They were both very disrespectful and insisted. I did not comply and obviously did not meet in person either one of them... wow.

Several men who wanted to sex text... especially those who message you after 11PM.

The married men... get the call reverse app folks and a phone number early on do your homework!

All of this in a matter of 8 weeks on a dating site. Way more drama and way less fun than I expected. So I am no longer a member of any site and will live my life single until something unexpected happens like we did before the digital age. Be careful out there!

Date of experience: November 8, 2016
Canada
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow frank s.
Unfollow frank s.
Share Review
Report Review

$#*!in. Pathetic
November 8, 2016

The owner of this page is a pervert and a sick woman hatter I think this web site should be closed for good 3 of my friends got a std 2 of them got hiv this web page is a std bank with no regards for human lives

Date of experience: November 7, 2016
New York
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Jim D.
Unfollow Jim D.
Share Review
Report Review

So, I initially signed up for this site, and everything was fine... for a couple of weeks. I was exchanging messages with some women, and all was good. Then, when I went to sign in one day, it said my pw was incorrect. I tried again, same response. I tried again, going extra slow, to make absolutely sure I was entering it correctly, same response. So, I requested a pw reset, and was advised that, if my email address was valid, I would be receiving a pw reset email. I never received such an email, even though my email address was valid and I had been receiving communication from this site (notifying me of new messages). I tried emailing POF through their help link. No response. I tried calling. Was told the only tech support was through email. Tried emailing. AGAIN. No response. AGAIN! So, I created another profile. This time, I had my browser save/remember my password. Then, the same thing happened. I tried signing in using the exact same pw (as saved in the browser), and I was told it was incorrect. Tried again, same. Again, same. So, I requested a pw reset. Again. Had to create another profile just to contact those I was communicating with. Again. Just waiting to be locked out of my third profile. But even that is not the ultimate issue. The ultimate issue is that I have received absolutely no response from POF from my repeated attempts to contact them to get help for this site. I was given the opportunity to contact POF through this site before writing this review, which I did. However, based on my experience, I have absolutely no confidence I will receive a response. With so may personal Web sites, and so many free personal Web sites (like POF), this lack of customer service is absolutely unacceptable. It's not the problems... every Web site is going to have problems. It's the complete lack of customer support that has be so discouraged, and inspired me to write this review.

Date of experience: November 7, 2016
Canada
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow John W.
Unfollow John W.
Share Review
Report Review

Not exactly the best experience if you're a guy. No messages. No attention. Nothing whatsoever. If you happen to be a guy who is somewhat good-looking but have little to nothing going for him, even the bottom end of the women on this site wont talk to you. Women in your own backyard don't want anything to do with you. What if you're a unattractive guy? Forget about it. You're less than a blip on the screen. These women wont even look at your profile. I have so many bad things to say about this site that I've forgotten some of them. Just like I ought to forget that I ever tried this site. My advice to you men is STAY AWAY!

Date of experience: November 7, 2016
California
105 reviews
140 helpful votes
Follow Jared I.
Unfollow Jared I.
Share Review
Report Review

Playground for psychos
November 6, 2016

Had a gf who wanted to drink every day who moved in with me from here and tried to kill herself when I broke up with her.

Date of experience: November 6, 2016
Illinois
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Ginger m.
Unfollow Ginger m.
Share Review
Report Review

Is great!
November 3, 2016

I thought it was a waste of time but it isn't I met the love of my life there we connect right away and we talked the same day all night we met went for a few dates& we are now 8 months, together as a boyfriend and girlfriend we can't be away from each other from one second he sees me or I see him every weekend thank you pof!

Date of experience: October 31, 2016
Ireland
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow John F.
Unfollow John F.
Share Review
Report Review

Rubbish
October 30, 2016

POF is woeful. Women are stuck up... Lads... avoid...

Date of experience: October 30, 2016