SportsCollectibles

Our reviews are monitored for authenticity

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Read more about our Review Guidelines and the process we have against fake reviews.

Reviews

Write a review
2.9
Reviews 53
5 Stars
42%
4 Stars
2%
3 Stars
2%
2 Stars
2%
1 Star
52%

California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Daryl P.
Unfollow Daryl P.
Share Review
Report Review

I purchased a signed book, but was sent only the ripped out page signed by the author. An absolute scam of a company who did not respond to any of my correspondence after delivery requesting a return. I paid $190 for what is, at most, a $10 article. Disgusting. Avoid at all costs. No contact from them at all. They should be closed down.

Date of experience: June 20, 2025
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Brian B.
Unfollow Brian B.
Share Review
Report Review
SCUM OF THE COLLECTORS MARKET
May 7, 2025

This company preys on the unknown selling other peoples products, without their knowledge. SportsCollectibles are lying scamming thieves the deserve to be tarred n feather. Our business is a victim of their site, they steal products we are selling and attempt to sell as their own products. If your in the Panhandle of Florida please come by our shop to see first hand dozens of items they claim as their own, in our shop on our walls waiting to be purchased. After several of my customers pointed out that eBay showed multiple stores selling our items I started investigating. Currently seeking legal assistant to go after these crooks.

Date of experience: May 5, 2025
New Jersey
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Corey K.
Unfollow Corey K.
Share Review
Report Review
Horrible service
September 20, 2024

I purchased something a week ago, received a receipt and nothing else. No tracking, nothing. I replied to their original email numerous times and no one has gotten back to me. I'm an going to call my bank to hopefully pull my funds back from this scam.

Date of experience: September 20, 2024
Wisconsin
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Chris g.
Unfollow Chris g.
Share Review
Report Review
Expensive Ebay Drop-Shipping
September 17, 2024

All it is is someone else's Ebay listing at an high markup, masquerading as their own inventory. I guess it's technically not illegal but it's still taking advantage of people who don't know any better.

Date of experience: September 17, 2024

See reviews of sites as you browse!
Get the Chrome Extension.

Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jessica D.
Unfollow Jessica D.
Share Review
Report Review
Knowingly defraud clientele
December 7, 2023

I purchased an item from this website with a UDA description in the title. I got the delivery wrapped in eBay tape and the item didn't have any authentication. I spent an hour digging around and realized they just purchased this item from eBay and added the UDA themselves in the title. They also excluded the images from the EBay seller that clearly shows this is a fake. The letter of authentication is missing punctuation and I could replicate in Word. They withheld this information knowingly from me and added false information. Not only this but they set me up and charged me a 300% mark up from the eBay price. The is active deception and fraud. Their website says they only sell 100% authenticated items but they knowingly sold a fake item and tried to cover it up.

Date of experience: December 7, 2023
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Kyle D.
Unfollow Kyle D.
Share Review
Report Review
Item never recieved
October 15, 2023

Recently I ordered a jersey and it said it was supposed to ship in 3 to 5 days, its been over a week and I haven't received a confirmation email and i put in a help ticket and also got no response. WOULD NOT recommend using this website, hopefully I can get my money back. I would attach "proof of purchase" but there was no confirmation or anything.

Date of experience: October 15, 2023
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Albert C.
Unfollow Albert C.
Share Review
Report Review
Horrible
May 5, 2023

Item i received wasn't JSA authenticated (or authenticated at all) as it was supposed to be. Returned it. The customer service was really bad. They also don't respond to emails. Not sure how they're still in business

Date of experience: May 5, 2023
Minnesota
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Ann H.
Unfollow Ann H.
Share Review
Report Review
I was nervous but everything went great!
December 8, 2022

I read a few bad reviews about this site which almost kept me from ordering but I crossed my fingers and decided to give them a shot. I am so happy I did! I ordered a sign framed photo and it got here super quickly and in perfect shape. I had to contact customer service via email and they got back to me very quickly.The only thing I wish they would change is sending email order confirmation. I did not receive any email about my order, not that it had shipped, or tracking information. This made me nervous but was very happy and excited it got here today. I ordered it on a Friday and it got here on a Wednesday so only 2 business days.

Date of experience: December 7, 2022
Michigan
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow M h.
Unfollow M h.
Share Review
Report Review

Here is what they do:

Scrape ebay's collectibles area, then import those items into their site at a huge markup. Then, if you are dumb enough to purchase it from them, they buy it from the unsuspecting seller on ebay (often after making a low ball offer to the seller), then the give the ebay seller their customers address making the ebay seller an unsuspecting drop shipper.

This is actually illegal.

How do I know this, they did this exact thing to a friend who sells autographs on ebay.

If you find your ebay products here, just have your attorney reach out to them so that you can preserve your rights.

If you read the other reviews about this site you will see that this is a well known situation.

I added images with an example of an item they are selling that is currently for sale on eBay by another seller.

Date of experience: July 19, 2022
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow John A.
Unfollow John A.
Share Review
Report Review
Way to expensive.
March 27, 2022

Better sites with better prices. Looks like a decent site, the way it's presented. I've been collecting autographed items for over 20 years and Superstar Greetings was by far the best.

Date of experience: March 27, 2022
South Dakota
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Stephen S.
Unfollow Stephen S.
Share Review
Report Review
Scam
December 10, 2021

Bought a jersey and then cancelled my order took my money and gave me a receipt. No customer service. No Nothing just Latin legalese in an attempt to scare me away. Stay away unless you like headaches.

Date of experience: December 10, 2021
Florida
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Matthew L.
Unfollow Matthew L.
Share Review
Report Review
They're scammers, DO NOT BUY
May 18, 2021

They steal these listings off ebay and proceed to sell it for a much higher price. I saw a listing for an autograph worth $400. I reverse searched the image and found the same exact photo being sold on ebay for $250! The seller on Ebay said he was aware of his prints being sold on this website, except he can't do anything about them. The website sells these listings for an insane amount and if you buy them, they buy it off the sellers from ebay THEN ship it to you. They are not the true holders of the item.

Date of experience: May 18, 2021
Virginia
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Van C.
Unfollow Van C.
Share Review
Report Review
Stay away
March 31, 2021

Bought an autographed picture and waited a few weeks without hearing anything. Finally got in touch with somebody and was told I would have shipping info within a day or two. They sent me an email with a usps link for my order and the link was blank. I called them back and when I was able to get in touch with them they told me they would issue a refund which I still haven't received. Do not do anything with these people.

Date of experience: March 31, 2021
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow BC A.
Unfollow BC A.
Share Review
Report Review
Bought and shipped to wrong location
December 21, 2020

Bought a puck online for it to get here in time for Christmas, was shipped to a completely different location. Called the company was told the warehouse it came from didn't ship to Canada so it had to go to their main warehouse. That would have been acceptable had they contacted me to let me know. Instead I had to call in a panic because it was out for delivery in the wrong country. I had to cancel the order because there was no way it would get here in time (which it would have if it didn't get shipped across the country initially!)

Date of experience: December 21, 2020
Louisiana
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow BC M.
Unfollow BC M.
Share Review
Report Review

I found my exact one-of-a-kind Bruce Lee Autograph with the exact same PSA serial number for sale on their site. My listing was on ebay and they simply copied my listing to sell it on thier site. They do not have my permission to use this item or any item of mine. Please do your research before purchasing anything with this company.

Date of experience: September 29, 2020
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Dan L.
Unfollow Dan L.
Share Review
Report Review
Stolen photo
May 21, 2020

I just purchased an item on eBay, a high value baseball autograph. I noticed shortly after, that their site had a photo of the exact, psa/dna serial numbered item on their site! Had to contact eBay seller and wasted 2 hours of my time having to research on the shadiness of this company so that I could be reassured about my legitimate eBay purchase. I also let the eBay seller know that this website was stealing his photos! Lol. Hoe can there be two copies of one vintage, slabbed and serial numbered autograph... super shady

Date of experience: May 21, 2020
California
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Nancy C.
Unfollow Nancy C.
Share Review
Report Review
False advertising
February 3, 2020

They stole my picture and claimed to have the exact same item-certificate of authenticity number, barcode and all!

Date of experience: February 3, 2020
California
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow K B.
Unfollow K B.
Share Review
Report Review
Not the real deal
February 3, 2020

They sold me an item and then when it went up in value, they cancelled my order! They are liars and cheats. And I also ordered something else that came with a "certificate" and it was not the real deal! They are fake!

Date of experience: February 3, 2020
Florida
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Glenn T.
Unfollow Glenn T.
Share Review
Report Review
No item shipped, not refund, no response
December 30, 2019

Ordered signed football on December 8th. Credit card was charged and I received email confirmation that i placed an order the same day. The confirmation included no shopping information or description of the item i ordered. On December 16th I contacted customer service for a status of the order because I needed to know when it would be shipping. According to the customer service ticket on their website, Derek closed by inquiry with the status of "resolved", even though i was not contacted and no information was provided to me. I have contacted customer service twice since my original inquiry was ignored and i have received no information from anyone. You may want to think twice before ordering anything from this company.

Date of experience: December 30, 2019
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Brian G.
Unfollow Brian G.
Share Review
Report Review
Great customer service
December 7, 2019

Great customer service from The sports collectibles team. My client loved their gift. Will shop again!

Date of experience: December 6, 2019