Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook
On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.
The company exhibits a mixed reputation, with some customers praising the ability to replicate discontinued fragrances and the quality of the products received. Positive feedback highlights satisfying scent matches and excellent customer service experiences, including quick resolutions to issues. However, significant concerns arise regarding product consistency, with many customers expressing disappointment over receiving items that do not resemble their original fragrances. Additionally, the lack of a return policy and perceived inadequate customer support have led to frustration among buyers. Overall, while there are loyal customers, persistent quality and service issues undermine broader customer satisfaction.
This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews
We monitor reviews for authenticity
I love the scent I ordered but when I ordered it I got the spray bottle. It comes out in a stream instead of a spray. If I'd known that I'd have ordered a open bottle to apply on my own the desired amount.
I requested Angel Fire as a Mother's day gift and she absolutely loves it. Thank you for making my Mom happy. :)" I also love the fact that you put my name w a message on the bottle. Now every time she looks at it she will have beautiful memories and I was the one that facilitated that. :)
I ordered the Jo Malone Vintage Gardenia scent match and it was done perfectly. Now, I can enjoy my favorite, discontinued fragrance again. Thank you!
There are no negatives I can say, only positives.
The scent is a perfect match, my wife's happy. This shipping was fast. Customer service kept me updated without me having to ask a single question and followed u p after delivery even. I am a customer for life now, and I would highly recommend them to anybody who's looking for that perfume which they remember and cannot find anymore because it's not being produced anymore.
These folks are legit!
ScentMatchers did a very good job at reinventing this fragrance; the fragrance had a hint of the original blend of spices; I love what ScentMatchers have done to create this fragrance for me.
Sent what they say matched. No Way! I sent the actual perfume to them 2 more no matches. I'm out my perfume and I'm out my money. They do NOT match. Don't waste your money. No guarantee with this company. Do not order Lilu from this placeplace.
"Have always used Cachet since the 70's. Love how you made the scent the same. Just love it. Very fast shipment also."
I just wanted to give you some positive feedback regarding my recent purchase with your company. I was so pleased to learn that your company does not conduct testing on animals! (Product is vegan!)That is why I decided to go ahead with the purchase. It was also a nice personal touch to have a name engraved on the bottle (as this order was a gift) I was pleasantly surprised to receive update emails through every step of the process! Your company certainly is all about 'Customer Service!' When my sister received her gift, she was elated and said she couldn't stop smelling her fragrance (Tuxedo) and also commented on the nice packaging.
Thank you for your attention to detail and making this shopping experience a pleasant one!
I will be a repeat customer in the future!
The "Desert Flower" fragrance was so like the original. It brought happy memories of me using it in high school. And also of buying it in the gift package for my grandmother. It was her favorite also. That was almost 50 years ago. Thank you for making this special for me. Vicki
They could not match my scent, which is really no big deal. However, they will not respond to my emails now. I saw several people saying the same thing on Facebook, and now they removed their community page so people can't complain. Do not buy from this company!
As soon as I received my bottle of a match to Safari for men by Ralph Lauren I noticed there was floating debris and a hair floating inside the liquid! They claim to respond to emails within an hour, 24 hours at the most. I have been emailing for days without a response. They also deleted my comments, pictures and videos off their Facebook page. All I wanted was a refund because debris and hair inside a cologne bottle is disgusting. I am disappointed and now angry they wont help me with this problem. There is no quality control in their matching/blending process it seems.
I have left 3 messages and sent 4 emails because their site states if it's not the right scent they will fix it. It's not even close and they are 100% non responsive. And this stuff is EXPENSIVE.
Gross feeling and smelling, took over a month to get to me, doesn't smell anything like what I ordered which was forever midnight from bath and body works. I have called and emailed with no response. I will be reporting to BBB and leaving reviews everywhere I can, I should have done my research, so many similar complaints.
The fragrance is nothing like the scent I ordered, and the bottle has no spray nozzle or way to access the cologne itself. Numerous email, phone and website form requests have gone unanswered.
Scentmatchers is amazing. I never thought I would ever have Absinthe by Christian LaCroix by Avon again. But Scentmatchers did it. The first bottle I ordered wasn't the right fragrance, a bit too light. I emailed Erica and they worked on a new bottle for me. They shipped it out and once I opened it, I knew, this was it! It's perfect, the Absinthe I remembered. And FYI, the bottles are huge! Even the original Avon bottle is smaller than Scentmatchers, so it's worth the price. They are true to their word in making the second bottle and shipping it for free, that's something that means a lot to me. I ended up giving my first bottle to my coworker who prefers light scented perfume, so they've made two ladies very happy! I will definitely order again and have recommended to all my friends. Thank you!
I order in March 23, got my order today April 27... 1 month later... the perfume was suppose to be August by Hollister smells nothing like it, smells so bad! What a waste! So upset. Don't be fooled by these people!
I have going on month #2 of my saga with Scentmatchers. At first I thought this was the answer to my discontinued fragrance prayers but it is actually a nightmare. Had I done my research I would have never chosen this company! After waiting several weeks for my order to ship and finally getting a tracking number; I was elated to soon expect my order but this elation was short lived. I checked the tracking number daily only to see that my package has never left Pontiac, MI. I sent several emails and after 2 weeks inquired about a refund only to be told that I can only receive a refund after I send the package back to scentmatchers. Humm. That would be difficult if I never receive it!?!? I was sent another email saying that they have contacted USPS and my package will be delivered but ground shipping takes 2-3 weeks.
So before I go postal and file fraud complaints with my bank, visa, BBB and the FTC; I decided to open an investigation with the USPS first. The conversation with them was nothing short of eye opening. Not only was I made aware that no other inquiries were made regarding my tracking number (essentially making them liars) but the whole premise for ground shipping is unbelievably false. In fact the woman said, "what is so combustible in 3.4 oz that they can't ship air? I just ordered Marc Jacobs perfume from Amazon and it was delivered to my house from across the country in 2 days!" It actually made me think well. Your right, all the fragrance companies ship fast, wth!
Since I am not ever going to receive my order or a refund, as I have tried to contact customer support over and over again with no resolution; I will let every avenue of consumer protection assist me in ensuring that this doesn't happen to someone else!
Had a question about my order and was answered in a very timely manner and very polite answer. Sweet! But the really best part was that my beloved fragrance that is no longer made in its original manner... ScentMatchers duplicated perfectly. Not sure how they managed to work that magic, but am in heaven! Mucho thanks and keep up the awesome work!
Kathy
I appreciated all their help and how wonderful they are to work with. Since my perfume was discontinued they matched it as close as possible and I am very pleased.
This an outstanding company with great customer service and wow I absolutely luv my Incredible that you did for me. It makes me happy every time I put it on!
Answer: Hello Jeanne, Perhaps you are referring to Blue Carnation by Roger & Gallet. Please send us an email to [email protected] for any further assistance. Thank you!
Answer: Hello Ashley, Greetings from Scentmatchers! We match discontinued fragrances (including the ones not listed on our website) all the time so that will not be a problem. You can order 8 by Abercrombie & Fitch reproduction by manually entering details from here: https://scentmatchers.com/ Please select "My Fragrance Is Not Listed" option from the drop down menu, and type in the fragrance details manually in the empty box next to "Type Fragrance Name:" option. On the same page, you can select bottle model and the message to be printed on bottle. After that, click on "Add to Cart" button to proceed with the order process. Unfortunately we do not sort the reviews fragrance-wise, but you can check the general feedback emails from our customers here: www.scentmatchersreviews.com For any further assistance, please send an email to [email protected]
Answer: Hello, Yes, we do have 90 days full refund policy in case you are not happy with the order. For any further assistance, please send an email to [email protected]
Answer: Hi, one of our customers ordered Woods reproduction. Please check their review here: http://www.sitejabber.com/reviews/www.scentmatchers.com#92
Answer: I ordered a different scent and it was not even close to the original. They offered to refund my money
Answer: Don't know what "salliage" is, it's not in my dictionary. But in the few days I've used my perfume, the scent is still noticeable by evening. Hope this helps.
Answer: Hi Nikki, Perhaps you can give it a try. We have a full refund policy (check below URL) in case you are not happy with your order. https://scentmatchers.com/pages/return-policy Thank you!
Answer: Hi Barbara, Yes, Raffinee is in our list of scents that we've already successfully matched found here: https://scentmatchers.com/ Please select "Fragrance Name" from the dropdown menu. On the same page, you can select the gender, bottle model and the message to be printed on the bottle. After that, click on the "Add to Cart" button to proceed with the order process. Please send us an email to [email protected] for any further assistance. Thank you!
Answer: Hello Carlie, Greetings from Scentmatchers! Yes, we have Ready by Abercrombie & Fitch listed on our website. You can order from the website URL given below: https://scentmatchers.com Please send us an email to [email protected] for any further assistance. Thank you!
Answer: Hello Eric, Greetings from Scentmatchers! I've checked, and you are in luck! Iquitos by Alain Delon is in our list of scents that we've already successfully matched found here: https://scentmatchers.com/ Please select "Fragrance Name" from the dropdown menu. On the same page, you can select bottle model and the message to be printed on bottle. After that, click on "Add to Cart" button to proceed with the order process. Feel free to contact us again for any further assistance.
Perfume and fragrance matching.

