Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish

1.5

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
411
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
444

We monitor reviews for authenticity

California
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow Brie T.
Unfollow Brie T.
Share Review
Report Review

It worked for me!
February 26, 2016

So I found out about POF from a friend of mine and started my page. After I wrote a nice profile about my self and posted a few pictures I started looking at guys profile. I took a couple of "test" that they have where they show you who you could be compatible with and you could put not interested, interested or maybe. From time to time I would talk to a couple of guys here and there but nothing serious. There was a profile that keep popping up over and over in my search. I read the profile before and thought this guy was attractive so I clicked "maybe interested" I had no idea that when you click "maybe" it shows the other person that you are interested in them. A few days later the guy I said "maybe" too decided to message me... now almost 4 years later I am on my way to saying yes to him for the rest of my life. In the end its not the website... its the person. Some people get on the site looking for love, well if they are really ready and put their all into it, then it can work (just like any relationship) Others go on for fun and games, which is fine, but if you are really trying to start dating someone and you know you want a relationship, don't even try to talk to the ones that is just looking for fun or to just be friends. Just my advice... but the site worked for me!

Date of experience: February 26, 2016
Florida
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow ROCHELLE R.
Unfollow ROCHELLE R.
Share Review
Report Review

Scam
February 24, 2016

I never authorized a continued payment plan. To my understanding it was $38.00 for 3 months. Now, I have been charged again and there is no way to delete my cardit card information or an actual phone number to call someone.

Date of experience: February 24, 2016
New York
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Becky C.
Unfollow Becky C.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammers
February 24, 2016

Please ladies be careful chatting with those so called military men! It's not worth the conversation. When I reported these situations I've been told they are fake profiles using stolen pictures. My last experience his profile didn't say his occupation. Or a good photo of him! Until we started chatting on hang outs... ladies military men are not allowed on these forms of communications. Be careful!

Date of experience: February 24, 2016
California
3 reviews
155 helpful votes
Follow Spirit W.
Unfollow Spirit W.
Share Review
Report Review

I tried the site with a 3 month trial. Just discovered today they automatically charged me for a renewal I did not ask for. Going back over the upgrade email it does say they will automatically renew but that part is conveniently off to the right of the email so it doesn't show up to notify you of the sneaky practice. I have sent an email to this company with the information they requested for a refund but they have not responded. Cant leave a message as their complaint/refund voice box is full. I have been forced to file a dispute for the charges on my Visa card through my account with them. DO NOT GIVE THEM YOUR CARD NUMBER ONLINE. ITS A TRAP! GO BACK...

Date of experience: February 22, 2016
California
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow rubi g.
Unfollow rubi g.
Share Review
Report Review

I met plenty of people from the site. Through the site I made friends and eventually after about a year of removing and returning to the site I found my partner today (: Never expected to find my partner through a dating site, but it's by far been my best and longest relationship. Honestly dating sites are basically all the same more or less

Date of experience: February 20, 2016
Illinois
2 reviews
53 helpful votes
Follow mike b.
Unfollow mike b.
Share Review
Report Review

I've been using this site for a few months now. Its not any better than Match, or OKCupid, or Our Time. You still get the stupid fake come on - "So and So wants to meet you"... NOT! I actually got a "reply" from a woman kindly turning down my request to strike up an acquaintance... I never sent her a message, and I never even saw a profile to send a message to! The only difference I see with this site is apparently more women in my town use it than the other sites. The absolute WORST thing though is POF slows down wiithout warning. One minute you're surfing profiles or messaging someone, and WHAM! You can't go to the next page, or get to your mailbox for 45 minutes to an hour... the pages just time out and the site becomes useless. My recommendation is, if you use this site, DO NOT opt for the paid subscription... you won't be happy.

Date of experience: February 18, 2016
California
2 reviews
50 helpful votes
Follow John M.
Unfollow John M.
Share Review
Report Review

No originality
February 18, 2016

The biggest complaint I have about this site is not really about the site at all. Instead, my complaint is about the women who post profiles.

I wish I had statistics about the percentage of women who write that they "love to laugh" and "don't want drama". There are many, many other cliches used as well. But in short, the primary message that most women on this site seem to want to convey is that they are seeking only good times and have no patience for a real relationship. Why would anyone want to date these immature, hedonistic, and spoiled women? Even more significant, why would anyone want to marry these women who appear to be only interested in fun and nothing else?

This could be a decent site, if only members would provide more detail about themselves, and avoid all the dating-site cliches like the ones I mentioned above. And members should exercise great caution to avoid sounding like children in search of nothing but good times.

Date of experience: February 18, 2016
Louisiana
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow George b.
Unfollow George b.
Share Review
Report Review

Great
February 18, 2016

I was married for 18 yrs. Finally it was my chance to live a little. Pof has brought me more $#*! than the once had bi girlfriend. Love this site. My biggest expense use to be fuel, no it's condoms. If you aren't getting laid off this site then you deserve to be single.

Date of experience: February 17, 2016
GB
1 review
55 helpful votes
Follow Jo G.
Unfollow Jo G.
Share Review
Report Review

I received a racist message... I cannot find a way to report this?

Date of experience: February 17, 2016
Illinois
1 review
16 helpful votes
Follow Laura R.
Unfollow Laura R.
Share Review
Report Review

Given it several tries
February 16, 2016

Met a nice guy... got a call from his girlfriend. Took a break, met a nice guy, found out he had SEVERAL girlfriends, the next day some dude started talking to me and I managed to get his last name... you figure if you are going to cheat your main Facebook profile shouldn't be of you and your girlfriend. Ya all the dudes on here just want booty, or several side chicks, dont expect more then that.

Date of experience: February 16, 2016
GB
3 reviews
32 helpful votes
Follow Aaron P.
Unfollow Aaron P.
Share Review
Report Review

I've been on the site for a couple of years on and off, and it truly is a nightmare of a site to the point I'm closing my account. Firstly the site owner feels you shouldn't send messages to people more then 9 years younger or older then yourself. Rather then giving users the ability to adjust age ranges of who can message them instead.

Secondly, if you're a genuine guy out there, like myself who is actually looking for a meaningful relationship, yes ladies we do actually exist if you look enough.

Forget POF, you will waste your time messaging and getting little in responses back on this site. Even if you share interests or talk about hobbies, interests and places they've travelled. Ratio wise, out of 10 messages sent, you might be lucky if you get 1-2 replies back. Can be very demoralizing.

Thus making the point of writing a meaningful message pointless, as an experiment recently. I created a female profile, with permission from a friend to use some of her photo's. Within 2 minutes of setting up the profile, it gained 11 mails from guys. In 20 minutes nearly 50 messages and 99+ Meet Me's.

I think it's got to the stage now, where women are getting so inundated with messages from guys. That most simply will not respond and those who do make an effort are being lost in the ton's of messages from sex addicts who aren't really looking for dating and a relationship.

Date of experience: February 16, 2016
GB
1 review
14 helpful votes
Follow Yasmin W.
Unfollow Yasmin W.
Share Review
Report Review

Ladies avoid if you are looking for anything but sex, from my experience lol l would rather be single than go back on this site. You will feel used and violated by what should be called scum.com. Lies and sexual abusive messages. L was warned about this site but tried it anyway, one of my biggest regrets. Do go there gals, it's messed up and a slimy slope to dissatisfaction and disappointment. Urrg!

Date of experience: February 15, 2016
Colorado
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Denise S.
Unfollow Denise S.
Share Review
Report Review

I met, dated, & married my husband of almost 2 years! Thanks to POF. I was one of the Lucky ladies to meet my prince charming on this website! There are some great men out there ladies, just stay optimistic!

Date of experience: February 15, 2016
Maryland
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow rosanne f.
Unfollow rosanne f.
Share Review
Report Review

Pof should be free
February 15, 2016

Because it ain't worth paying for! The desirable men are a minority, and complete jerks just looking to hook up. Or a lot of losers.
Have to be better sites..

Date of experience: February 14, 2016
GB
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow maggie t.
Unfollow maggie t.
Share Review
Report Review

Be warned
February 14, 2016

I joined plenty of fish uk in november.
I canceled in early december but they are still taking £37 a month from my account

Maggie tighe

Date of experience: February 14, 2016
Australia
2 reviews
58 helpful votes
Follow justin L.
Unfollow justin L.
Share Review
Report Review

This Website is full off;
* Very Ugly & insecure Men & Women*
* Single Mothers with lots of Children, looking for $$
*Good Looking women, that just want to do the Slut rounds & in a Cosmetic/Commercial World to make themselves feel better, & get the most messages
*Drug & Alcoholic's
*Inauthentic & very insecure people

You have been Warned!

Match.com is even worse, full of Fake Profile's/Scammer's & fake messages, hacking into
Your Email account.
If u want to meet someone, the internet dating game, is a no go. Go to the Supermarket, go for a walk, go the the library or for a walk on the beach or go to your local food & produce & Art & craft markets to meet someone,

Date of experience: February 11, 2016
Arizona
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Cynthia W.
Unfollow Cynthia W.
Share Review
Report Review

THEY DO NOT MIND ASKING YOU TO SEND THEM MONEY... SOME BOGUS, TRUMPED UP BULL$#*! STORIES ABOUT NEEDING MONEY BECAUSE THEY ARE IN ANOTHER COUNTRY, NEED FOOD, ETC. WELL YOU TOOK YOUR DUMB $#*! OVER THERE!

TWO FOR SURE! BERNARD MILLER AND JAMES WATERS ( I am sure its probably not the real name... but beware; they so dumb they may use the same name again)

Date of experience: February 8, 2016
New York
1 review
18 helpful votes
Follow Gina B.
Unfollow Gina B.
Share Review
Report Review

Stay Away
February 8, 2016

Been on here twice, the first time for about 6 months and it ended with a wife calling me from my number that she found in her husband pocket. So I left the sight. Then after several after that I thought I might give it one more try. Several guys responded to my profile and most were only in meeting and having sex. No Thanks. Please don't waste your time.

Date of experience: February 7, 2016
Colorado
1 review
44 helpful votes
Follow Alfonso O.
Unfollow Alfonso O.
Share Review
Report Review

POF a dating nightmare
February 6, 2016

POF is by far the worst dating service that You will ever use. I used to be a member and all I got was fake profiles, scammers and unhappy ladies that are trying to make men pay for what their exes did to them. I was as polite as you can possibly be and got My profile deleted just because I politely turned down some of these ladies. The POF management won't even look into it, they will just take their word. If you're looking for an honest dating service, try OKcupid. POF is just garbage.

Date of experience: February 6, 2016
New York
1 review
19 helpful votes
Follow Nan p.
Unfollow Nan p.
Share Review
Report Review

Bottom Feeding
February 6, 2016

Dear Ladies,
Don't lower your standards or think you will find the man of your dreams in this cesspool. In my market I have seen and experienced men on here that are only looking to find a woman to play around with. Rarely are they genuine or worse yet, who they pretend to be in their profiles.
In fact, I saw my loser ex boyfriend put on a new profile on there just 2 weeks after we broke! We were together almost 3 years! I stood by him through thick and thin! He says in his profile that he's had a few casual relationships in recent years! Lie. His says he's self-employed--? Another lie. He has no job, no car, and just found out he has major health issues. He also spent a year in jail! He's a disgraced disbarred lawyer! Has an ex wife he hates, but claims in his profile that he"s great friends with his ex-- who is a real nut job, and gets jealous if he has a woman in his life. He's a real hot mess! However, he's also a narcissist of the highest order, and is looking for his next victim. Someone to use and abuse and drain every penny from, because he has no money! He's on social services in New York State. Lives for free in his parents dumpy apt., that they need to sell. So in other words, Beware of the type of bottom feeder men on this site! They are rarely sincere or who they say they are. Because the site is free, it attracts guys of the lowest common denominator for the most part! Same men have been on there for years!

Date of experience: February 6, 2016