New York Shirt Company

Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

website thubmnail of New York Shirt Company
New York Shirt Company

Our reviews monitored for authenticity

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Read more about our Review Guidelines and the process we have against fake reviews.

New York Shirt Company Reviews Summary

New York Shirt Company has 125 customer reviews and ranks 103rd in the T Shirts category. Common review topics include order, 2 shirts, 2 weeks.

Write a review
Reviews that mention popular topics
Ohio
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Cindy M.
Unfollow Cindy M.
Share Review
Report Review
November shirts
October 2, 2020

I love my shirts. Their comfortable and I get compliments on how cute they are. I will be ordering more shirts. They answered any questions I had and they were easy to get ahold of.
Thank you

Date of experience: October 1, 2020
Nevada
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow Barbara R.
Unfollow Barbara R.
Share Review
Report Review
Only 1/2 my orders
October 1, 2020

I ordered 2 shirts from this company and only received 1, when I reached out to them to ask what had happened to my other shirt that I had paid for I was promptly dumped into the "complaint dept" from which I never got a response ( I knew that I wasn't going to so it was no big surprise). Save your money and don't ever buy from this company because you will never get what you paid for and no one there wants to make it right, all they'll do is take your money! 1111

Date of experience: October 1, 2020
Iowa
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Denice M.
Unfollow Denice M.
Share Review
Report Review
DONT BUY FROM THIS COMPANY
September 29, 2020

I ordered from them and got my shirts in about 4 weeks. BUT THEN I'VE ORDERED 3 MORE TIMES CLOSE TOGETHER, MORE THAN $350.00 AND HAVE'NT RECEIVED MY ORDERS, I GUESS THEY GET YOU AS A CUSTOMER THEY TAKE YOUR MONEY AND THEY ARE DONE WITH YOU. I'M CONTACTING MY BANK.

Date of experience: September 29, 2020
Alabama
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Dianna S.
Unfollow Dianna S.
Share Review
Report Review
Shirts not arrived
September 21, 2020

I ordered three shirts August 20th as if today September 21st they still have not arrived. They sent an email saying they were shipped; but when I click on the tracking number it says they are still waiting for them to be picked up. I can not believe it takes this long to send three shirts. If it dies they need to hire more help. When people write messages like this it knocks business out. But good messages would pay for the added help. I'm tired of waiting. My next step will be your BBB

Date of experience: September 21, 2020
New York
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Shelby L.
Unfollow Shelby L.
Share Review
Report Review
Haven't recieved orders
September 19, 2020

Don't bother ordering from this company! My first order was 30 days ago, 2nd order was 21 days ago. Keep getting the runaround about shipping mix up and being overloaded wirh orders. Still not shipped but they took my money immediately! SCAM!

Date of experience: September 18, 2020
New York
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow ELLEN F.
Unfollow ELLEN F.
Share Review
Report Review
Poor quality
August 8, 2020

Image on shirt is off center. Customer support not responding. Another order not shipped after weeks of waiting. Looking at reviews, you will either have a good experience or bad. Nothing in between.

Date of experience: August 8, 2020
California
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Anet G.
Unfollow Anet G.
Share Review
Report Review
Bad Quality
May 30, 2020

The shirts are made in China and very poor quality. The fabric smells and won't go away with washing.

Date of experience: May 30, 2020
Ohio
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Amanda B.
Unfollow Amanda B.
Share Review
Report Review
Seriously avoid this company
May 18, 2020

I placed an order early Feburary of 2019 was so excited I tackled it early for a shirt for my birthday in late march. I saw other reviews saying they received theirs in 3 weeks or so. So I figured it should be in. I did receive a tracking number in a week. Thought cool will be in soon. Checked tracking a week later still in process of getting label. Waited another week. Same message. So figured maybe they are very busy. After a full month (now in mid march) I messaged and asked. I was directed to keep checking my tracking and be patient. I was ok with that. I waited another week. Still on waiting on label. After reaching out again. Label was said to be created and shipment set to on it's way (it is passed my bday now and I am ok still because I am very patient. Fig I could still rock it in march) nothing else happened for 2 weeks. By now I am getting a bit impatient it is now April. I asked politely if they could tell me what was going on. (I have all messages and emails with them if you want proof) I told them it was well past my bday but wanted it anyway. They replied kindly and I waited again. A month passed nothing! Now may. I messaged again said i have no idea what was going on. Wanted to know if it was coming from China because that would be understandable. I was given some cookie cutter message then finally they said no it is shipped from USA. I asked if they are extremely busy and just didnt get to it yet. I was again talked to easily and put at ease. But I was rather disappointed and unsure at this point. Well life happened and I didnt get to them for another month or two. They sent an ad to me asking me to buy more shirts. I said hell no still dont have the one I ordered and paid 17 for (that's with shipping) so they apologized and messaged me to just keep checking tracking it will update soon. I said no, I have been told that for 5 months now. I asked to either have it sent or have a refund. They never really said anything. Again life got In way and another month or two passed. I was frustrated. Needless to say this went on until 2020 when i threatened to refund and get BBB involved. I finally got my shirt super fast. Yea, I feel they are scammers or something. Because if I had not been diligent and kept going at them like I did, they would have kept my money for no product. So moral of story... DO NOT BUY FROM THEM! GO TO A PERSON WHO MAKES SHIRTS AND GET THE SHIRT YOU WANT FEOM THEM INSTEAD.

On a positive note, I do love my shirt. Just took a yr or longer to get here.

Date of experience: May 18, 2020
Oklahoma
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Judi G.
Unfollow Judi G.
Share Review
Report Review
Excellent product
February 27, 2020

Made very well with easy to read print. True to size. If you wear a small buy a small. There are no returns. I bought the ones for being born in April

Date of experience: February 25, 2020
Texas
2 reviews
17 helpful votes
Follow Patrese A.
Unfollow Patrese A.
Share Review
Report Review
March T-Shirt
February 18, 2020

I have recently purchased two shirts from this company and I am VERY pleased with them. They looked exactly like the photos on there site. One for myself and my little cousin who is graduating this year from high school. I also, received them within the allotted time frame specified. They are in New York and I'm in Texas, so I thgt that was pretty good.

Date of experience: February 17, 2020
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Theresa A.
Unfollow Theresa A.
Share Review
Report Review
Two for one shirts
February 13, 2020

Great Deal. Shirts are good quality for sure. I got the 2 for one April Girl. Love them. Very comfortable. Thank You. New York shirt company.

Date of experience: February 12, 2020
Iowa
3 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Deb C.
Unfollow Deb C.
Share Review
Report Review
LOVE 'Em!
February 4, 2020

This company's shirts are absolutely fantastic! I have bought several of them and will probably buy several more!

Date of experience: February 3, 2020
Minnesota
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Cindy U.
Unfollow Cindy U.
Share Review
Report Review
Tsirts
February 2, 2020

Love them. The quirky sayings are so neat. Fit true to size. Fast shipping. Have given for gifts also.

Date of experience: February 1, 2020
West Virginia
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Carla L.
Unfollow Carla L.
Share Review
Report Review
Love NY Shirt Company
February 2, 2020

I've ordered several t-shirts. I also ordered a hoodie. EVERYTHING is of the highest quality. Fits are true to size. Couldn't be happier! I've already got my eye on several other products... including coffee mugs!

Date of experience: January 31, 2020
Georgia
1 review
16 helpful votes
Follow Sandra S.
Unfollow Sandra S.
Share Review
Report Review
Great variety of products
January 31, 2020

I have been ordering shirts for sometime now. They are great T-shirts. I enjoy all the different sayings, not for the month I was born. I have only had 1 issue. My order came as the wrong size. They quickly resolved it, by remaking the entire order at no additional charge. The process seems a little slow, but all made to order. The shirts are good quality also and true to size with little to no shrinking. I have at least a dozen shirts from NYShirt Company.

Date of experience: January 31, 2020
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Betty R.
Unfollow Betty R.
Share Review
Report Review
I'll Mourn You Till I Join You. Tee Shirt
January 31, 2020

I bought two of these shirts. My daughter and I love it. It gave us a sense of comfort, a sense of peace. It was a form of closure. I thank you soo much. We would always say this each time we visited my son's grave. I truly thank you.

Date of experience: January 30, 2020
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Tracy S.
Unfollow Tracy S.
Share Review
Report Review
Most 4x drown me and are loose, but this is tight fitting.
January 25, 2020

Most 4x drown me and are loose, but this is tight fitting. So it runs small. I'm ok with this because I have never bought from you before. This fits more like a 2x but I do like it, I am losing weight so I'm not to worried about it.

Date of experience: January 23, 2020
California
1 review
13 helpful votes
Follow Jimmy P.
Unfollow Jimmy P.
Share Review
Report Review
The shopping process is what I was most impressed with.
January 25, 2020

The shopping process is what I was most impressed with. They navigated my package every step of the way. It showed up earlier than expected. I love my new shirt and will for sure order from this site again.

Date of experience: January 23, 2020
Philippines
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow david c.
Unfollow david c.
Share Review
Report Review
I was pleasantly surprised
January 25, 2020

Since I ordered this online via Facebook, I didn't have high expectations. I mostly ordered it for the saying on the shirt. I was pleasantly surprised. The T-shirt is well-made, fits well, and is a higher quality cotton than on other shirts I've paid more for.

Date of experience: January 23, 2020
Philippines
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow stephanie g.
Unfollow stephanie g.
Share Review
Report Review
True to size.
January 25, 2020

True to size. Retains shape after washing. I did not dry in dryer. This October girl loves her T!

Date of experience: January 23, 2020