New York Shirt Company

Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

website thubmnail of New York Shirt Company
New York Shirt Company

Our reviews monitored for authenticity

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Read more about our Review Guidelines and the process we have against fake reviews.

New York Shirt Company Reviews Summary

New York Shirt Company has 125 customer reviews and ranks 103rd in the T Shirts category. Common review topics include order, 2 shirts, 2 weeks.

Write a review
Reviews that mention popular topics
Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Deborah C.
Unfollow Deborah C.
Share Review
Report Review
Horrible online service
July 19, 2021

I ordered $50 worth of shirts June 8th 2021. Today is July 19th 2021. I have sent many many correspondences I have sent emails I have tried finding a customer service phone number I've even gone so far as to chatting with the credit card company that paid them in full. Never again. As of today still no shipping when I track it

Date of experience: July 19, 2021
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Wendy G.
Unfollow Wendy G.
Share Review
Report Review

Sorriest shipping ever never ordered from these people you will never get your order it's been 8 weeks and I still haven't received my order

Date of experience: July 15, 2021
Georgia
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Charlene P.
Unfollow Charlene P.
Share Review
Report Review
Rip off
July 14, 2021

I've order me some shirts from this company and I have yet to receive my shirt and they want return my money! Don't order from this company poor customer service and service period.

Date of experience: July 14, 2021
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Susan F.
Unfollow Susan F.
Share Review
Report Review
Poor customer service
July 12, 2021

Ordered a shirt a month ago! Took my money real quick, but no shirt! Do not order from them! At this point I would just like my money back!

Date of experience: July 12, 2021
Texas
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Lily L.
Unfollow Lily L.
Share Review
Report Review
I haven't received my shirts
June 15, 2021

I paid in April and needed the shirts for bday in June. I no longer need the shirts my birthday has past. They are giving me excuses that something went wrong w parcel. I just want my refund at this point

Date of experience: June 15, 2021
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Sneed R.
Unfollow Sneed R.
Share Review
Report Review

Run don't order from this company you will never get your order and they will not refund your money back

Date of experience: June 1, 2021
Tennessee
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Tina T.
Unfollow Tina T.
Share Review
Report Review
This Company Lies
May 31, 2021

They are very vague about the shipping timeline, Please read the reviews before you order Especially the negative reviews, who wants to wait a month or two for an order that claims to be shipped within the United States, I want a refund they can keep their shirts!

Date of experience: May 31, 2021
New Hampshire
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Sarah B.
Unfollow Sarah B.
Share Review
Report Review
Horrible customer service!
May 29, 2021

I am deeply disappointed in this company! You run an ONLINE business which means your orders are all shipped out.
That being said I ordered 2 shirts that were never delivered and instead of just shipping me out 2 new shirts ( which would be tax deductible under losses) u want me to pay for half my shirts again.
What lind of business doesnt care about their customers? In a single mother who never buys anything for herself. The one time I do I get screwed because there was a delivery issue. Now I'm out 30 dollars and no t-shirts. How bout u just send me half my money back. In gonna make sure everyone heres about what an awful company you guys are to your paying customers! Awful! You should be ashamed of yourselves taking money and not supplying the goods!.
I do taxes so i know this is just poor customer service and has nothing to do with money!

Date of experience: May 29, 2021
Illinois
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Brittany H.
Unfollow Brittany H.
Share Review
Report Review
Wrong shirts and missing half my order
May 25, 2021

I ordered 14 shirts from this company on 5/13/21 had to reach out to them multiple times on finding out order number and proof of purchase since it wasn't emailed to me. A few days later I got a email saying My order would ship in 2 stages okay fine. The. I got an email saying My full order was shipped. Yesterday 5/24/21 I received my order to open and realized they sent me multiples of 3 shirts I didn't order. Rhere was no packing slip with the order and now trying to track out is a pain how do u guys not have a system to track correct orders received or shipped out and a refund forget about it. I contacted PayPal since I made the payment thru them to get an email back saying they ate forwarding My complaint to the right department for the merchant. Then i got another email from the company saying they will look into it but still nothing.

Date of experience: May 25, 2021
Georgia
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Margaret V.
Unfollow Margaret V.
Share Review
Report Review
Great Shirts, Great everything!
May 23, 2021

Beautiful shirts, everything was positive! Had no problems whatsoever. Tired however of seeing many bashing the company on social media. So I left the page.

Date of experience: May 22, 2021
North Carolina
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Gwendolyn A.
Unfollow Gwendolyn A.
Share Review
Report Review
Good Products!
May 19, 2021

Always try to correct your order if mixed up! The shirts are comfortable and was well. I like the products and wear! Will buy them again as needed

Date of experience: May 19, 2021
Florida
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Christina W.
Unfollow Christina W.
Share Review
Report Review
Have not received any of my shirts!
May 18, 2021

Please help! I had ordered my items back in April. And here it is almost the end of May! These T-shirts are supposed to be graduation gifts. Not only that, but I spent about $160.00 on them. Where are they? I'm home every day. No one has knocked on my door to deliver them to me. So if your showing them delivered it was NOT to my house! Please, resend these items to me or give me my money back. I'm really upset over this.

Date of experience: May 18, 2021
Iowa
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Diana H.
Unfollow Diana H.
Share Review
Report Review
Shirts
May 15, 2021

Still haven't received my shirts I've already paid for, and they still keep sending me more messages to buy more

Date of experience: May 15, 2021
Wisconsin
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Liz M.
Unfollow Liz M.
Share Review
Report Review
Terrible company
May 8, 2021

DON'T DO BUSINESS WITH THIS COMPANY! Terrible company to deal with. I ordered 3 T-shirts April 3rd. Over a month later I still haven't received my items. When I emailed the company about my items I received a response that they are having shipping & tracking issues. Appears to be a regular problem with this company as others have stated that they have the same issues. There are plenty of reputable companies to support. This one DEFINITELY ISN'T one of them.

Date of experience: May 8, 2021
Utah
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Debra Y.
Unfollow Debra Y.
Share Review
Report Review
ZERO PRODUCT
May 6, 2021

Order on March 30,2021 $35.51 cleared my bank on April 1,2021 as of May 6,2021 still no product, no tracking number. They say to contact them at *******@newyorkshirtcompany.com, but every link I click on does not allow me to contact them. I will not place another order with this company even if it does exist! This is a scam! I am deleting my account with them, I don't want further contact with scammers! It says I have to select an overall rating, I don't even like giving one star! My OVERALL IS BIG ZERO! All I have as proof of any order is the order

Date of experience: May 6, 2021
Michigan
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Katrina K.
Unfollow Katrina K.
Share Review
Report Review
Nothing at all
May 6, 2021

I ordered some shirts like 4 weeks ago and still have no clue when I might actually receive my order which they had no issues when they took my money but seem to have a script to send to people who aren't happy I wish I would of read these reviews before I ordered from this company no response from a real person only email and recordings I want a refund I guess I'll have to report my card stolen to get my money back this company sucks

Date of experience: May 6, 2021
Washington
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jill K.
Unfollow Jill K.
Share Review
Report Review
Did not receive my order!
May 4, 2021

I ordered the buy a shirt get a shirt 15% off deal on April 6th 2021. This is May 4th 2021 and still no shirts. Has anyone else had this issue?

Date of experience: May 4, 2021
Oklahoma
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Barbara H.
Unfollow Barbara H.
Share Review
Report Review
Don't Bother ordering!
April 1, 2021

I ordered three shirts the first part of January... here it is April 1st and all I've gotten is the run around... no shirts! I've e-mailed several times and, I swear, my answer sounds like it's being written by a 5 year old. They even sent, what I assume, is a bogus shipping label to UPS on March 22nd and no more tracking information. They have my money but I don't have their shirts! Starting to think this is a scam!

Date of experience: April 1, 2021
Arizona
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Gail V.
Unfollow Gail V.
Share Review
Report Review
October shirts
February 18, 2021

I ordered two shirts on January 24 and it is now February 18 and still nothing- e- mail said it usually takes 2-3 weeks for the shirts to be received they were fst to take my money but no word on where my shirts are

Date of experience: February 18, 2021
California
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Denise D.
Unfollow Denise D.
Share Review
Report Review
Sucky exchange/return policy!
February 11, 2021

I have seen this company advertising on Facebook and Instagram for some time. Their shirts look like something I would wear and other things I saw that I would love to send to family and friends. I avoided them for months until recently, I thought I would order and possibly keep them around for future orders. I love most of what I see here and don't mind showing my faith on my clothing; it's a great conversation starter.
I ordered a hoodie from them or so I thought. What I got was a sweatshirt. When I saw the item on the website I thought it was a cute and appropriate statement for my granddaughter who had just moved into her own place. Knowing it was cold where she was I thought I ordered a hoodie. At the time I placed the order I did not recognize that there was a button to select either sweatshirt or hoodie. What I saw on the website was the hoodie. When I got the order in the mail and recognized 1- I had gotten a sweatshirt, and 2-on the website the item selection buttons, I instantly emailed their customer service. They answered promptly, first with this message. "As these Tshirts are custom made for you, no replacement or refund is possible on them. If you want we can redo your order for you."
I emailed them again and told them this was not a custom order and that I was not looking for a replacement or refund, just an exchange (sweatshirt for a hoodie). The price was the same all I wanted was a return label to return it for my desired item. I got this message back within a matter of a few hours; "I apologize but we do not have an exchange policy.
Regards
Emma Brooks
Customer Care Associate"

Their exchange policy does not match that of the company they look to be. Most companies understand that mistakes can be made and depending on how old they are, they are very open to working with their customers to assure their satisfaction; NOT this company! I am not sure how old or new they are but they miss the mark when it comes to assuring customer satisfaction.

Date of experience: February 11, 2021