Democratic Underground

Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Democratic Underground

Democratic Underground

1.1

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Democratic Underground?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Democratic Underground Reviews Summary

The company, Democratic Underground, has garnered a reputation as a highly moderated online community for Democrats, with many users expressing frustration over its restrictive policies. While some appreciate the platform's commitment to preventing hate speech and fostering a safe environment, a significant number of reviews highlight concerns regarding censorship and an echo chamber effect, stifling open dialogue and diverse viewpoints. Users frequently report being banned for expressing dissenting opinions, leading to a perception of hostility towards constructive criticism. Overall, the sentiment suggests a decline in the site's initial promise of vibrant discussion, now overshadowed by a culture of conformity.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
4
value
2
quality
4

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Washington
2 reviews
42 helpful votes
Follow Harold M.
Unfollow Harold M.
Share Review
Report Review

DU is corrupt. They purged and continue to purge all progressives who call out anything real. They say we can't relitigate the primary but it's Clinton people who always do and bait with no punishment. Fall for it and respond and youre banned. They don't deserve the name Democratic and definitely not Underground. I posted 20,000 comments but bring up that someone is pro-War or pro-Surveilance and the sock puppet military contractors who pervade the place will flag you. All I see is horrific hate speech about Bernie... a guy we all loved and knew nothing about a few years ago. Wow. DU needs to be revoked.

Date of experience: July 21, 2017
Ohio
1 review
32 helpful votes
Follow Mike K.
Unfollow Mike K.
Share Review
Report Review

In the last couple of years, Democratic Underground has devolved from a haven for diverse progressive voices into a bizarre Hillary Clinton fan club, which now--even among the site's administration--values blind fealty above all else.

Highly recommended for anyone who thinks the best way to advance democratic principles is to don blinders, smear progressives, and ban anyone not in complete lockstep with the inexorable, decades-long rightward march of the Democratic Party.

Also, take care not to call attention to the outside rantings of high-profile anti-Semitic DU members. Pointing out such things is strictly verboten, and will get you ejected in no time.

Finally, blaming everyone from the Russians to Bernie Sanders (but definitely not Clinton's anemic political abilities) for the current mess you're in is the order of the day. Do that, and you'll fit right in.

Date of experience: July 20, 2017
Colorado
1 review
22 helpful votes
Follow Karen K.
Unfollow Karen K.
Share Review
Report Review

I used to love DU
July 20, 2017

This was a place where liberals could get news, discuss just about anything, and commiserate about the problems in the country. Now, all they do is make excuses for losing the election and praising Hillary. No dissent is allowed. They are still fighting the primary instead of fighting the Trump administration. I don't feel welcome anymore.

Date of experience: July 20, 2017
Connecticut
1 review
21 helpful votes
Follow Mark R.
Unfollow Mark R.
Share Review
Report Review

Owners decided to transform a vibrant self moderating progressive forum into a message board dedicated to evicting anyone who doesn't support Hillary Clinton 100% forever and always. Their current moderation system encourages head hunting and rewards it with permanent "flagged for review" evictions. Bashing the left wing of the party is totally acceptable, even the slightest criticism of the right wing will make you a target.

Date of experience: July 20, 2017
Colorado
1 review
26 helpful votes
Follow Roy T.
Unfollow Roy T.
Share Review
Report Review

Democratic Underground (DU) used to be a great site to discuss Democratic issues and news a visitor might not see elsewhere. Since before the 2016 primary, though, it's turned into nothing but a vast echo chamber where, in a parallel reality far removed from this one, former Secretary Clinton was the very embodiment of a perfect candidate and anyone who supported any other candidate is a traitor to the party. Mention something positive about Bernie? Brace yourself, because you're about to get swarmed, mostly with shrieking and paranoid nonsense about how Sanders cost Hillary the election. Say something mildly critical of Democrats in general? You're a disruptor who must be punished, and why do you love Trump? I went there for a long time and (stupidly, I now realize) even donated money to them over many years. No more. It's the Left's dark twin of Free Republic but it was once so much more. ZERO STARS (1 here because zero isn't currently an option recognized by the software).

Date of experience: July 20, 2017
Gully F.
GB
1 review
22 helpful votes
Follow Gully F.
Unfollow Gully F.
Share Review
Report Review

Once, Democratic Underground was a cool place to be. It was friendly and fun. All the elements that made it so have now gone. And by "elements" I mean "people". It was a meeting place for diverse and interesting people from the U.S. and beyond. United by their left-leaning political and social views. I was a member of DU for years until I was banned. My crime was that I didn't accept Hillary Clinton as the new Mother Theresa (the old one was bad enough).

The interesting people have gone. Banned or put on temporary "under review" status - which is, in effect, the same thing. Now DU is a great dull echo chamber, the Clinton supporters who were allowed to stay endlessly still fighting last year's election, scrabbling around for reasons and pining for what might have been if only their candidate hadn't been less popular than Donald Trump.

Once, dissent was welcome there, a starting-point for discussion. Now it isn't. Don't just take my word for it - join up there and hear how DU was hacked by the Russians during the election. (Really).

Date of experience: July 15, 2017
Florida
1 review
29 helpful votes
Follow Saul G.
Unfollow Saul G.
Share Review
Report Review

This used to be such an awesome site to use for late breaking news and progressive views of the world. Then, the 2008 presidential election/primary where Queen Hillary wasn't the nominee and it all went downhill. Even the 2004 election, where not 100% of everyone was behind Kerry was bad, but NOTHING compared to how things were after 2008. Sadly, the PUMA's got their revenge in the 2016 primary and anyone who did not lick the taint of St. Hillary was called a communist, a closet republican, a misogynist, a woman hater, etc.

Of course, it should come as no surprise. Does no one remember the Great Gay Purge? Where DOZENS of highly esteemed DU'ers were banned solely because they were gay? I do. I remember that well, because those people were my friends. Then in 2016 anyone who was remotely critical of Hillary was FFR'ed. There are people who have been "flagged for review" for MONTHS and no response from Admin.

Of course, it really should come as no surprise, seeing that admin works for DNC and also runs that cesspit Discussionist (like FR but without the pleasnatries). So he's taking money from both left and right wingers, and DU has definitely taken a right-wing turn since the 2016 primary. We used to stand up against DINO's but now they're embraced. We use to stand up against non-progressive policies but now, pragmatism is the key and if demos' have to adapt Republican policies such as anti-choice and anti-woman laws to be elected, then that's just how it is. Up is down and down is up.

I have not donated to DU in years. I will not line the pocket of a DNC shill and his lawyer wife.

Date of experience: July 14, 2017
South Carolina
2 reviews
26 helpful votes
Follow John H.
Unfollow John H.
Share Review
Report Review

DU used to be kinda fun. It had your usual over the top folks, but some boards were fun and informative. NOT ANY MORE. It's a Hillary Clinton cult site that engages in more propaganda and censorship than North Korea. They now have zero sense of humor and will not tolerate even mild criticism of Clinton or, most importantly, themselves. It's a joke and as stupid as any Teabagger site.If they can't ban you, you will go on "review" (which comes with not being able to post) forever. Don't bother... unless you want to go see why Dems will continue to lose for years to come.

Date of experience: July 14, 2017
Nebraska
5 reviews
89 helpful votes
Follow Clint L.
Unfollow Clint L.
Share Review
Report Review

If you don't 110% agree with their obviously biased and probably paid narrative in EVERY WAY, you will be banned.

The censorship here is far more rampant than it is on any reddit sub, even the ones most accused of bias/abuse. If you support Bernie and hate Hillary expect a ban in minutes!

Date of experience: April 29, 2017
Richard S.
NL
2 reviews
28 helpful votes
Follow Richard S.
Unfollow Richard S.
Share Review
Report Review

if you say something that isnt 100% following democratic parties believes you get banned

example: someone posted fabricated julian assange news(democrats hate him i wonder why maybe because of the damaging facts that are released :P)

all i typed was that it was fake news and yep i got banned

Date of experience: October 18, 2016
Kenya
51 reviews
314 helpful votes
Follow ASAP R.
Unfollow ASAP R.
Share Review
Report Review

Don't Be Fooled
July 10, 2016

Extreme left-wing propaganda being propagated here.Not much debate going on

Date of experience: July 10, 2016
New Hampshire
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Victor N.
Unfollow Victor N.
Share Review
Report Review

Great site
June 1, 2016

Great progressive site. Very biased... towards facts.

Date of experience: May 31, 2016
Minnesota
43 reviews
192 helpful votes
Follow Tony B.
Unfollow Tony B.
Share Review
Report Review

I have trashed other propaganda rags, but this is quite possibly the worst website on the web. There is no debate, just mind numbing agreement and conformity.

Date of experience: November 20, 2013
Colorado
1 review
14 helpful votes
Follow rob j.
Unfollow rob j.
Share Review
Report Review

I naively joined this site thinking it was a debate forum encompassing a wide range of viewpoints. Its not. This is a hard line left wing extremist website where everyone has more or less the same viewpoint. If you disagree them you will be booted off. If you tell them you're an Independent they will translate that to Gun-carrying Tea Party Right Wing Religious Nutjob. I'm convinced that most of this sites members would like to enact a Communist Police state since the only debate they appear to have is how they can best achieve control over society.

Date of experience: December 31, 2012