Check out our latest communities fighting
AI scams on Reddit and Facebook

business logo of Craigslist

Craigslist

1.9

On SmartCustomer, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Craigslist?
grey stargrey stargrey stargrey stargrey star

Craigslist Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of the company is significantly marred by customer dissatisfaction, particularly regarding its platform's functionality and customer service. Users frequently express frustration over the arbitrary removal of legitimate posts, with many feeling that the site is overrun by scams while genuine listings are flagged without explanation. Additionally, the lack of responsive customer support exacerbates these issues, leaving users feeling unheard. Despite some recognition of the platform's potential to connect individuals, the prevailing sentiment is one of disappointment, with many users seeking alternatives due to these persistent challenges.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
82
value
75
shipping
39
returns
37
quality
64

We monitor reviews for authenticity

California
4 reviews
10 helpful votes
Follow Daniel H.
Unfollow Daniel H.
Share Review
Report Review

Hit/Miss
January 13, 2017

I assume this one can be positive or negative depending on how lucky you are... Unfortunately the feature that many businesses nowadays have;(

Date of experience: January 12, 2017
South Carolina
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow John S.
Unfollow John S.
Share Review
Report Review

Asked why my listing was deleted and got nothing but immature insulting answers! Who ever The Bottom Line is should be fired! He makes assumptions and shoves them in your face. I'm 55 years old and can't believe I have to text with what seems to be a child that wants to feel like he has some kind of power or something? I guess it's just a big ego he has because he thinks he has an important job? His first answer to me was: How many ads are you not posting to by-dealer. What the hell does that mean? He asked a question and didn't answer mine? Instead of answering: if you list too many listings, someone will think your a dealer and delete your listing. If I sell something for 10.00 on Craigslist and I meet up with someone and they buy my item, what does being a dealer on not matter? By the way I'm not a dealer! Also they said I have over 200 listings. I only have 20 listings! Please get some more reliable people on the texting and tell them to help not insult someone! Very disappointed.

Date of experience: January 10, 2017
Virginia
6 reviews
29 helpful votes
Follow Broken h.
Unfollow Broken h.
Share Review
Report Review

I dated this hot mess for 12 weeks last year. Worst decision of my life! Has lived at home mooching off his wonderful mother for many many years! He doesn't want a relationship due to the fact that he his bipolar and not on needed meds, he snaps in a second. Smokes pot, has slept with many women in exchange for pot! This man by his own words is only good for one thing an incapable of a relationship! He states in his ad he wants another child? He and his ex wife both drug addicts didn't even raise the child they had! Her mother did! Steer clear of this loser unless you are looking for a user, drunk, taker, whore that sleeps around for drugs, and can even afford to support himself. This is my experience with him and he will never change, never fully commit, mooch off of you, sleep with everything and anything! He has a bad temper and will snap on a dime. And absolutely no talking while he is watching the news! Lol he's a nut bag. Incapable of loving anyone but him.

Date of experience: January 1, 2017
California
5 reviews
26 helpful votes
Follow Roy W.
Unfollow Roy W.
Share Review
Report Review

I wanted to add to this review that Craigslist is located at 222 Sutter Street near Kearny St. In San Francisco, CA. Someone noted their corporate address is in New York but their physical address is on Sutter Street in San Francisco and this is not widely known. They have offices there in an office building with other companies...

Craigslist has changed a lot over the years... At one time if you wanted to post you needed a verified email and phone and they would call and check before you could post.

Frankly I wondered why so many foolish and flaky ads then I found anyone can just enter an email there and post anything. Years ago I sold of a big lot of collectibles and Craigslist was helpful - More recently I've been unable to even buy when I tried (and this was several times)...

What is most scary are the singles ads so here are some things to be wary of... If a guy or gal looks too good to be true it is probably not their photo. If you use google chrome you can click on the photo and do an internet image search on the picture. You will often find the photo is a scam and not the person who posted so check it out and see before replying if you use chrome.

Another thing to check are singles ads which are posted in the late night or early AM. Why because often they are from offshore posters who are posing as locals. Craigslist was intended for local to local business but I now see ads posted which are far away. I just saw a posting from a supposed local gal who looked good that is until you read it and she admitted she is in jail 2,000 miles away but posted as a local and needed financial help to reply until she gets out of jail and comes to live with you...

On buying on CL. If it does not feel good don't go for it. In our locality people have been robbed and injured by meeting someone they don't know to buy on CL. My personal experience is sellers are so flaky you can't even buy if you want to. I wanted to buy some old tapes and contacted a guy who lived in a nearby community - no problem he said I can bring them into town. Two hours before we were to meet he calls and can't make it. Yet he ran the ad for the old tapes for a month afterword with no takers. I guess he threw them out as the ad finally went away with him trying to get $5 for the lot I had offered him $25 on (I mean why bother with this BS?).

Another time I wanted to buy a Monster Power item. I wrote the guy Thursday could we meet Saturday - no reply. I went out of town and get an email Sunday saying if I can meet him in a hour we can do business (one day after my suggested time and four days later when I'm out of town with 2 hours notice).

Craigslist is delusional and a total waste of time. I'm wondering how long they will survive with almost everything there appearing to be a sham lately. Use it if you will but you probably won't be successful or satisfied with the results that is is you get lucky enough to have anything real happen there in the first place,

Date of experience: December 26, 2016
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Will L.
Unfollow Will L.
Share Review
Report Review

Dont use this app
December 18, 2016

This app sucks I posted hundreds of things on the old Craigslist app got a new phone original Apple used wasn't there try this one try to post my car 3 times it kept saying Craigslist has stopped will continue to use other websites because Craigslist is not what it used to be

Date of experience: December 18, 2016
Colorado
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Robert J.
Unfollow Robert J.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammer employers
November 29, 2016

I found a job on craigslist for a delivery driver for a flower shop in colorado springs called colorado springs florists. I worked for this person for about 2 months but she wrote me 3 bad checks during that time, and was atleast 1 week late every time she paid me. Her own bank told me she had been doing it for awhile to all her drivers. Craigslist doesn't monitor their jobs and its a daily chore for me to mark fake jobs as spam. I have over 1300 jobs marked as fake jobs right now. And the ones that are real are jobs like this where an employer is looking to screw you over.

Date of experience: November 28, 2016
Colorado
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Esther M.
Unfollow Esther M.
Share Review
Report Review

Ripped off
November 26, 2016

I purchased motorcycle rims from a guy named Joel who said they were brand new, I then took them to have tires mounted, I was then told they were used and was out of true, and that it would cost me $300.00 to have them trued. I contacted Joel and he was ok with giving me my money back at 1st, and after about an hour he turned it around and said I damaged the rims, his post has a picture of a rim and his phone # is *******247... he is a liar and a theif, and now he is harassing my boyfriend about it... the only reason for this review is to let everyone know the rims are not safe

Date of experience: November 26, 2016
California
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow asa a.
Unfollow asa a.
Share Review
Report Review

Review for Personals and Car section:

Craigslist we all go on it to find something we need and then it turns out to be the opposite.

Ive been on craigslist for awhile. It has addictive nature; you surf and think you've had enough and then before you know it you're back on it again.

To get to the point I search and browse the casual encounters alot. It's a mess in there because its all practically bots try to scam people to get phone numbers and collect pictures. I literally cannnot find anyone and when I do its very rare. Gay people post alot on the w4m, mw4m sections which is unwanted as well as personally email you on your posts. I don't have any hate towards them but it defeats the purpose. I think the website is not in popular demand for young people hooking up I have yet to find a website that does. Pretty much all online interaction with people is a waste of time, you are better off meeting and planning in person.

Car section: Horrible. All sorts of people selling stolen cars or cars with no registration and or proof of ownership. Again not a very trustworthy site for dealing with people. Background checks should be ran if people want to sell their cars to other people. I have had close chances to buy cars and then all the sudden seller doesn't want to sell anymore.

In short criagslist is something that sounds great but in practice not so great. With the personals, things for sale, jobs section they are all riddled with people who want more for less and people who take a chance at screwing over others for the benefit of themselves.

There is no technical or customer support so that is the biggest downer for this site. You either find a way to work it out with someone online or you lose out.

Date of experience: October 20, 2016
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Kim B.
Unfollow Kim B.
Share Review
Report Review

I came here because no recourse for leaving feedback/reviews. I live in Austin and tried to hire a guy who rents out Moonwalks/Bouncehouses for $75. He has 3 (Hello Kitty, Spiderman & a Purple Castle). I spoke to him over the phone and hired him for a kid's party. There was no contract but he assured me he would make it. I sent a note to Administrators of Craigslist after he was a no show. But likely nothing will be done to regulate people like this. He is running a business using Craigslist. He doesn't have a name listed so no easy way to give him a yelp review. I guess Buyer Beware and I'd recommend meeting anyone you hire before your event to get something in writing

Date of experience: October 17, 2016
Oregon
4 reviews
6 helpful votes
Follow james b.
Unfollow james b.
Share Review
Report Review

Craigslist do not monitor site they leave it to users very stupid idea! I took off 53 false ads
On one page for Las Vegas thats over half they should never allow this to happen. Buyers
All want to lowball you only less than 5 percent are sincere. Many many scammers will
Try to con you quite pathetic Craigslist does nothing about it. Sellers put high prices lots
Of salvage cars with stupid prices! I have sold a number of cars here but is it worth the hassle
Probably not!

Date of experience: September 30, 2016
North Carolina
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow kim h.
Unfollow kim h.
Share Review
Report Review

I travel for business and rented a "small luxury house" from an elderly couple who appeared to be deeply religious. On the day I rented the apartment, the deposit check was cashed, even though he made me write out 2 different checks. The wife often invited herself over to visit me when I was home, without calling. They would invite me to dinner and coffee. They would keep me there talking about jesus and mostly the anti Christ. (this should have been my red flag) for hours. When I would go to work, the wife would sneak into my house and turn the air conditioner up to 78 degrees. I usually keep it on 74, which is very reasonable. When I confronted them, on august the 5th 2016 at 8 pm, Russell Thibodeaux told me that since he told me previously, he would pay the electric bill for my 800 square foot postage stamp for me not to worry about it. He also admitted that Phyllis Thibodeaux had been entering my apartment while I was not there, which is illegal. On the day I moved out, he showed me electric bills totaling 90 to 100 dollars a month and said that it was " in the contract " that I pay it. After 19 weeks of him paying the bills, and never mentioning it, he decided to be pejorative and take it out of the exorbitant $ 1000 deposit, which he did not hold. I believe that there is one meter for the electricity for the rented apartment, since it is in his back yard and for some unknown reason he decided I should pay for it. Therefore, this Pentecostal minister lied to me so that I would not pursue appropriate legal action for his wife entering my residence while I worked. He is a criminal and a charlatan.

Date of experience: September 28, 2016
Kenya
6 reviews
62 helpful votes
Follow David W.
Unfollow David W.
Share Review
Report Review

I would not recommend it
September 24, 2016

To be honest, I wouldn't recommend Craigslist to anyone. I bought a phone that was listed as unlocked, only to later find out that it wasn't. If only it had been tested when the seller was met. Very saddening

Date of experience: September 24, 2016
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jake R.
Unfollow Jake R.
Share Review
Report Review

If you search for movers in the Chicago area on Craigslist, you may see CHICAGO SKYLINE MOVERS adds posted every day. If you see their add, they look like they are highly rated, professional, and reliable. This is the ultimate in false advertising! I called and scheduled a move for my daughter in Chicago, they assured me repeatedly they would call beforehand and arrive on time. They did neither on move day, I called repeatedly and no one answered, no one showed up. I had to stay in Chicago another day to schedule other movers that were actually cheaper and showed up on time. Please to not give these flakes any consideration, your move will happen with other movers, but not with these unprofessional jerks.

Date of experience: September 6, 2016
Florida
3 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow kathy l.
Unfollow kathy l.
Share Review
Report Review

I hire this man and his Son to Put up Cameras and set up The DVR He came with out any Tools and expect to Use mine Then Try to drill a Hole into My wall I told him it was Block and you have to have the right Drill Bit to go Thru the wall He did not Listen Now I have a Hole He Left me a MESS The Cameras do Not record they only live play so i have to hire some one else to come do A Job this man screwed up@ night the camera are all white so Im not sure what he has done. Do Not hite this person waste of time and your Money

Date of experience: September 2, 2016
New Mexico
6 reviews
9 helpful votes
Follow Stephen W.
Unfollow Stephen W.
Share Review
Report Review

Back in the day...
August 29, 2016

This used to be such a great site. Now you get a couple of text a day regarding paypal, cashier's checks etc. What a shame!

Date of experience: August 29, 2016
Florida
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Antonio R.
Unfollow Antonio R.
Share Review
Report Review

Watch for job interviews asking you for money up front $100 or more. Plus osha SCAM!

Date of experience: August 26, 2016
Kenya
43 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Liam C.
Unfollow Liam C.
Share Review
Report Review

Can't get worse
August 26, 2016

Completely no checks on their system. It is like a cesspit market for anyone 'selling' anything. Stay away, please

Date of experience: August 26, 2016
Virginia
10 reviews
25 helpful votes
Follow barely a.
Unfollow barely a.
Share Review
Report Review

I have used craigslist.org for many years and with pretty good success. (Since they offer the most comprehensive listings and depth of listings of any similar service). They also seem to be pretty pro-active about warning people of possible scams and they seem to be able to keep your email private with their masked system of email replies.

What I wanted to mention specifically was that when I recently listed some furniture items for sale, I got back a text within 5 minutes, almost immediately after I made the listing.

The text had my listing title with, "still up for sale?" amended to it, and when I replied, they came back with,
"okay... I'll be paying with a cashiers check and wait till it clears your bank before pickup is scheduled. Thanks Alex"

I was born at night, but not last night, and I smelled a rat. But I replied- "sure".

Then they said, "kindly send me your name and address so that I can issue out the check for you"
Needless to say I cannot imagine any buyer in their right mind willing to buy something sight unseen, and before discussing any specifics, offering to send you money. Obviously a complete scam. But the point is the crooks are becoming much more sophisticated if they can create some algorithm or software which can pick up a new listing, send off a text to respond to it with their bogus offer, and harvest names and addresses for some yet undefined but assuredly devious purpose.
Actually, I am pretty envious. I wish I was smart enough to do that. Not really. I hope they reap what they sow. We all have to look out for each other if we want a decent world.

Date of experience: August 18, 2016
Mississippi
9 reviews
36 helpful votes
Follow Paula M.
Unfollow Paula M.
Share Review
Report Review

I find that men seeking women are also In the men seeking men section. I've learned to Google every pic I see and find interesting where it's at on other sites.

Date of experience: August 15, 2016
Texas
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Jen O.
Unfollow Jen O.
Share Review
Report Review

Mike's TV Install in Dallas was a great value and service all around. Mike was professional, quick, and mounted my TV beautifully without any mistakes or mishaps. I would highly recommend this service to anyone looking to mount any size TV on a wall or even brick wall, with all the wires hidden behind the wall!

Date of experience: August 13, 2016